{"version":113,"empirical_calibration":false,"full_macro_integration":false,"protocol":{"q_grid":[0.0,0.05,0.1,0.15,0.2,0.25,0.3,0.35,0.4,0.45,0.5,0.55,0.6,0.65,0.7,0.75,0.8,0.85,0.9,0.95,1.0],"floors":[0.9,0.95,0.975,0.99],"groups":["displaced_free","displaced_debt"],"metrics":"Both cohorts must pass; receipt gate mandatory. Year1 anchor is control year 1, not pre-automation consumption.","boundary":"Discrete passing grid points only; no interpolation, monotonicity or welfare claim.","scope":"Common q only; fixed source prices/incomes, unchanged baseline .90 rule. Funding gate checks surcharge receipt schedule, not full macro sustainability."},"annual_financing_cost":{"quarter_end":0.1551258389261745,"december":0.8797621107266439},"controls":[{"q":0.0,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.0,"tax_timing":"december","groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.05,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.05,"tax_timing":"december","groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.1,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.1,"tax_timing":"december","groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.15,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.15,"tax_timing":"december","groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.2,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.2,"tax_timing":"december","groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.25,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.25,"tax_timing":"december","groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.3,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.3,"tax_timing":"december","groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.35,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.35,"tax_timing":"december","groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.4,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.4,"tax_timing":"december","groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.45,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.45,"tax_timing":"december","groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.5,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.5,"tax_timing":"december","groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.55,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.55,"tax_timing":"december","groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.6,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.6,"tax_timing":"december","groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.65,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.65,"tax_timing":"december","groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.7,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.7,"tax_timing":"december","groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.75,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.75,"tax_timing":"december","groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.8,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.8,"tax_timing":"december","groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.85,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.85,"tax_timing":"december","groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.9,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.9,"tax_timing":"december","groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.95,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.95,"tax_timing":"december","groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":1.0,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":1.0,"tax_timing":"december","groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}}],"cases":[{"q":0.0,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"owners_only","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":4.229150363244116e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.0,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"per_capita","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":4.229150363244116e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.0,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"displacement_cohorts","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":4.433786671143025e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":4},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702676205094438,1.7113822969900807,1.7235112117565339,1.7337877322443709,1.746993533815705,1.7549386830681626,1.7626833334155474,1.770241330653396,1.7776159089867087,1.7848329450837996,1.7919022904847484],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,0.999962763988803,0.993654822962181,0.9959144317431957,0.9970390110070652,0.9999622063364352,0.9999790197147174,0.9999914226705776,1.0000000000000004,1.0,1.0000000000000004,1.0000000000000002],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9994863739779511,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.993654822962181,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.506668800007058}}},{"q":0.0,"tax_timing":"december","policy":"owners_only","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":4.229150363244116e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.0,"tax_timing":"december","policy":"per_capita","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":4.433786671143025e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":10},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.0402589723409883,1.7025267030705722,1.71546419716746,1.7250647450497973,1.7324425599123767,1.7410089824412258,1.749318227120283,1.7574278998709414,1.7653501212351888,1.7730971165765708,1.7806800301182089,1.7881090736138163],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,0.9999873471872835,0.9998749631159422,0.9960248368423272,0.9968121260641847,0.9962654507455738,0.9965367069968427,0.9967764360100353,0.9970099521095337,0.9972369815722237,0.997457947812408,0.9976732192348706,0.9978831340910304],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9988236407847303,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9960248368423272,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066243123876246}}},{"q":0.0,"tax_timing":"december","policy":"displacement_cohorts","receipt_schedule_supported":false,"max_collection_gap":0.31212235045201886,"first_collection_gap_month":"0004-12","max_cash_error":4.888534022029489e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":17,"displaced_debt":49},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.033870328393685,3.8722719918923363,3.6660292208692424,3.415327415163102,3.1204802109643945,2.7819188409723883,2.407088676372573,2.4296654896456187,2.440083781675214,2.450366905842513,2.4601913198152223,2.473620051827975,2.4868945458954657,2.497409487049762,2.507526068022504,2.5172721866909216,2.526673160281239],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,0.9939372938684481,0.9878013070762152,0.9799085506997721,0.9697192782033358,0.9563999715316746,0.9386061310831478,0.9166666666666666,0.9166666666666667,0.9166666666666665,0.9166666666666666,0.9166666666666667,0.918157909840709,0.9197226155988331,0.9203901096053251,0.9210279354844104,0.9216383828998213,0.9222235085979353],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9530645743098969,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9166666666666665,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5877857072588613},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.2186622436471732,2.923438897839348,2.7403212558679257,2.4956860532802616,2.2443485594897257,1.9560103377396731,1.6484905418678009,1.2742313219749866,1.2623440445051441,1.2730904795338545,1.2829510637027082,1.3092136008304303,1.3286483764673052,1.3418863526337377,1.3498247532518228,1.3575867787097102,1.3651837005881067,1.3726258120500083],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,0.9702436755203876,0.9158832759605448,0.9038684853731744,0.8797459563886507,0.8609415497579002,0.8353701147020565,0.8079708047720332,0.748341857876931,0.732936323033259,0.7356431294638629,0.7377790463823162,0.7493812057750714,0.7570751695566348,0.7612682422272048,0.7625088906683718,0.763712099923528,0.76488037961671,0.7660159928020872],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.8479564793303747,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.732936323033259,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.3756382689273579}}},{"q":0.05,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"owners_only","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":3.524291969370097e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.05,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"per_capita","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":3.7971403799019754e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.094388073073812,4.215302017060482,4.155331139147921,4.057637155697408,3.9192396505408604,3.740329746698256,3.5210973007777646,3.2618455086263998,2.962981558010958,2.6250024147443103,2.6496316655876333,2.6609970750744645,2.6722150287115176,2.6829325712272007,2.693199287073906,2.703048997932224,2.712512444971091,2.7216173678465583,2.7303888746481344,2.73884975087942],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.999806452062523,0.9998081850890189,0.9998017412639401,0.9997933908896698,0.9997825714864791,0.9997686544236798,0.9997506879822432,0.9997272024445486,0.9996958270943986,0.9996525001903064,0.9996557292102475,0.9996571991243756,0.9996586377105564,0.9996600008908991,0.9996612965588264,0.9996625303526355,0.9996637073249836,0.9996648319844045,0.9996659083681937,0.9996669401029512],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9997215933333131,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9996525001903064,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6409979474590344},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.359738378207233,3.408669339618813,3.3165511405085177,3.1910954047252096,3.0309175473421086,2.8359603214353912,2.6059755072769035,2.3405994164145696,2.03938325475066,1.7018271033906995,1.7213981581264686,1.7296691161586224,1.7380241997514978,1.746147056662144,1.7540629980200186,1.7617859477259885,1.7693288257185358,1.7767034040518488,1.7839204401489395,1.7909897855498882],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9997641403166861,0.9997628044844705,0.9997516126364505,0.9997373009377585,0.9997188639619579,0.9996949023224225,0.999663168352161,0.9996198717544985,0.999558133777658,0.9994640960189111,0.9994701856323425,0.999472717770871,0.9994752512081662,0.9994776909986827,0.999480046910442,0.9994823249924102,0.9994845307704331,0.9994866692347617,0.9994887449061421,0.999490761890475],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9996105516968458,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9994640960189111,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5064161310967686}}},{"q":0.05,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"displacement_cohorts","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":4.9112713895738125e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":2},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.091217617971672,4.212067165443065,4.1520351628936005,4.0542830835044095,3.915830291443582,3.736867710808059,3.5175850176322667,3.2582852434707172,2.959375426284417,2.6213523950048714,2.645981645848194,2.657347055335025,2.6685650089720783,2.679282551487761,2.689549267334466,2.699398978192784,2.7088624252316515,2.717967348107119,2.7267388549086946,2.7351997311399807],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9990322603126155,0.9990409254450948,0.9990087063196997,0.9989669544483488,0.9989128574323952,0.9988432721183993,0.998753439911216,0.9986360122227438,0.9984791354719926,0.9982625009515326,0.9982786460512372,0.9982859956218785,0.9982931885527826,0.9983000044544955,0.9983064827941317,0.9983126517631772,0.9983185366249184,0.9983241599220222,0.9983295418409681,0.9983347005147558],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9986079666665654,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9982625009515326,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6401066510746868},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3565679231050924,3.4054344880013954,3.3132551642541976,3.1877413325322106,3.0275081882448296,2.832498285545193,2.6024632241314047,2.3370391512588866,2.0357771230241197,1.6981354296720876,1.7108791967274235,1.7194556853097946,1.7343245772767082,1.7424803970931053,1.7504129782805793,1.7581359279865487,1.7656788059790962,1.7730533843124092,1.7802704204095,1.7873397658104488],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9988207015834311,0.998814022422353,0.9987580631822538,0.998686504688792,0.9985943198097887,0.9984745116121122,0.9983158417608039,0.9980993587724918,0.9977906688882898,0.9972960171766961,0.9933627152295592,0.993570984663146,0.997347731290495,0.9973789305158477,0.9974002345522104,0.9974116249620505,0.9974226538521643,0.9974333461738085,0.9974437245307096,0.9974538094523753],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9977546492975096,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9933627152295592,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5053175922862594}}},{"q":0.05,"tax_timing":"december","policy":"owners_only","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":4.5929482439532876e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.05,"tax_timing":"december","policy":"per_capita","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":3.865352482534945e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.090685551977021,4.211524292420764,4.151482031930505,4.053720202876864,3.9152581325639346,3.7362867117053775,3.516995586031724,3.257687759525905,2.9587702450085103,2.6207398484396016,2.645369099282925,2.656734508769756,2.6679524624068094,2.678670004922492,2.688936720769197,2.698786431627515,2.7082498786663822,2.7173548015418496,2.7261263083434257,2.7345871845747114],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9989023353995683,0.9989121638785537,0.998875619140476,0.9988282618275732,0.998766901959651,0.9986879743958864,0.9985860816709223,0.9984528886042054,0.9982749501997205,0.9980292311830875,0.9980475438601923,0.9980558801551964,0.9980640387806304,0.998071769758421,0.9980791178543821,0.9980861150448772,0.998092789984942,0.998099168243733,0.9981052727178872,0.9981111239748682],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9984210777622842,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9980292311830875,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6399570736537841},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3560358571104425,3.4048916149790944,3.3127020332911017,3.187178451904667,3.0269360293651832,2.831917286442513,2.601873792530863,2.336441667314075,2.035161464944708,1.6974387461604536,1.7164548360767378,1.7247240143627587,1.7330630338676676,1.7411768604236342,1.7490900367167161,1.7568163759113307,1.7643686769915536,1.7717585994265892,1.7789967952476302,1.7860930172422462],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9986623736299263,0.9986547977510285,0.9985913256440925,0.9985101599895714,0.9984055987323489,0.998269705558652,0.998089733319002,0.9978441861786256,0.997488917837099,0.9968868627127796,0.9966000169945055,0.9966152381030012,0.9966222630168995,0.99663279873069,0.9966464111731173,0.996663027223608,0.9966825688903818,0.9967049633554088,0.996730142250991,0.9967580412875467],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9976372515117454,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9966000169945055,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5051102787654806}}},{"q":0.05,"tax_timing":"december","policy":"displacement_cohorts","receipt_schedule_supported":false,"max_collection_gap":0.3021358355476312,"first_collection_gap_month":"0004-12","max_cash_error":4.3655745685100555e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":17,"displaced_debt":48},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.072705012487718,4.193178542244474,4.132789626806521,4.033870328393685,3.8722719918923367,3.6660292208692424,3.4153274151631026,3.120480210964394,2.7819188409723883,2.4001761201311176,2.4275419544014767,2.4401701871646226,2.4526345800946814,2.464542960667661,2.4759504227195563,2.486894545895465,2.4974094870497625,2.5075260680225036,2.5172721866909216,2.526673160281239],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9945116769978419,0.9945608193927691,0.9943780957023794,0.9939372938684481,0.9878013070762153,0.9799085506997721,0.9697192782033359,0.9563999715316743,0.9386061310831478,0.9140342294198803,0.9158654971303283,0.9166991266307681,0.9175149891741511,0.918288086953214,0.9190228965493131,0.919722615598833,0.9203901096053253,0.9210279354844103,0.9216383828998213,0.9222235085979353],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9519821468286359,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9140342294198803,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5860977338164065},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.338055317621139,3.3865458648028053,3.218662243647173,2.9017704427303066,2.742498906294298,2.4958747949645503,2.244542346975345,1.9562307647349597,1.650873748133741,1.2626409464426158,1.2506839878283114,1.2620911929310612,1.300135969485932,1.3254992234622534,1.3338683734249879,1.3419942145472026,1.349932615165288,1.3576946406231758,1.3652915625015722,1.3727336739634735],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9933118681496317,0.9932739887551435,0.9702436755203875,0.9090947723031088,0.9045867623227629,0.8798124890894833,0.8610158874526791,0.835464254349881,0.8091388800722698,0.7415349594670393,0.7261663152019728,0.7292872971421009,0.7476614680581087,0.7587029386969508,0.7600495683154174,0.7613294335860002,0.7625698212949465,0.7637727777746431,0.7649408121147556,0.7660761868841183],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.8467030261956929,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.7261663152019728,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.3721685622933021}}},{"q":0.1,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"owners_only","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":3.61524143954739e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.1,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"per_capita","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":4.433786671143025e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.093595459298277,4.214493304156127,4.154507145084341,4.056798637649158,3.9183873107665406,3.7394642377257066,3.5202192299913904,3.2609554423374787,2.962080025079323,2.6240899098094506,2.6487191606527736,2.6600845701396048,2.671302523776658,2.682020066292341,2.6922867821390457,2.702136492997364,2.711599940036231,2.7207048629116986,2.7294763697132742,2.7379372459445603],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9996129041250462,0.9996163701780377,0.9996034825278799,0.9995867817793395,0.9995651429729581,0.9995373088473596,0.9995013759644865,0.9994544048890973,0.9993916541887972,0.9993050003806129,0.999311458420495,0.9993143982487513,0.999317275421113,0.9993200017817984,0.9993225931176527,0.999325060705271,0.9993274146499673,0.999329663968809,0.9993318167363872,0.9993338802059024],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9994431866666261,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9993050003806129,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6407751233629475},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.358945764431698,3.4078606267144584,3.315727146444938,3.19025688667696,3.0300652075677887,2.8350948124628417,2.605097436490529,2.339709350125649,2.038481721819025,1.7009145984558394,1.7204856531916084,1.7287566112237622,1.737111694816638,1.7452345517272838,1.7531504930851587,1.7608734427911283,1.7684163207836758,1.775790899116989,1.7830079352140795,1.7900772806150282],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9995282806333723,0.999525608968941,0.9995032252729014,0.999474601875517,0.9994377279239155,0.999389804644845,0.9993263367043217,0.9992397435089969,0.9991162675553159,0.9989281920378217,0.9989403712646846,0.9989454355417418,0.9989505024163323,0.998955381997365,0.998960093820884,0.9989646499848202,0.9989690615408658,0.9989733384695235,0.998977489812284,0.9989815237809501],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9992211033936913,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9989281920378217,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5061445951588358}}},{"q":0.1,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"displacement_cohorts","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":5.979927664157003e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":1},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.087254549093995,4.208023600921292,4.1479151925757,4.050090493263161,3.9115685925719834,3.73254016594531,3.5131946637003932,3.2538349120261136,2.9548677616262418,2.616789870330572,2.641419121173895,2.6527845306607256,2.664002484297779,2.674720026813462,2.6849867426601666,2.694836453518485,2.704299900557352,2.7134048234328194,2.7221763302343955,2.7306372064656816],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9980645206252302,0.9980818508901895,0.9980174126393992,0.9979339088966973,0.9978257148647904,0.997686544236798,0.9975068798224316,0.9972720244454876,0.9969582709439853,0.9965250019030649,0.9965572921024745,0.9965719912437571,0.9965863771055654,0.9966000089089913,0.9966129655882634,0.9966253035263546,0.9966370732498367,0.9966483198440441,0.9966590836819363,0.9966694010295115],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9972159333331307,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9965250019030649,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6389925305942521},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3526048542274163,3.4013909234796227,3.3091351939362967,3.183548742290963,3.023246489373232,2.8281707406824452,2.598072870199532,2.332588819814283,2.0312694583659443,1.6935865925718114,1.706822438610945,1.721386503965795,1.7297965871856937,1.737934512248405,1.7458504536062798,1.7535734033122496,1.761116281304797,1.76849085963811,1.7757078957352006,1.7827772411361493],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9976414031668621,0.9976280448447058,0.9975161263645076,0.9973730093775844,0.9971886396195778,0.9969490232242243,0.996631683521608,0.9961987175449833,0.9955813377765798,0.9946245358309669,0.9910072992157792,0.9946866897142491,0.9947438469289701,0.9947769099868252,0.9948004691044207,0.9948232499241013,0.9948453077043284,0.9948666923476173,0.994887449061419,0.9949076189047505],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9959629318686268,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9910072992157792,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5039639856356651}}},{"q":0.1,"tax_timing":"december","policy":"owners_only","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":3.5925040720030665e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.1,"tax_timing":"december","policy":"per_capita","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":4.0245140553452075e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.086190417104696,4.206937854876692,4.146808930649509,4.048964732008072,3.91042427481269,3.7313781677399502,3.51201580049931,3.25263994413649,2.9536573990744275,2.615564777200033,2.6401940280433562,2.6515594375301874,2.6627773911672405,2.6734949336829232,2.683761649529628,2.6936113603879464,2.703074807426814,2.712179730302281,2.720951237103857,2.729412113335143],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9978046707991368,0.9978243277571077,0.9977512382809517,0.9976565236551468,0.9975338039193022,0.9973759487917732,0.9971721633418448,0.9969057772084111,0.9965499003994408,0.9960584623661753,0.9960950877203845,0.9961117603103931,0.9961280775612608,0.996143539516842,0.9961582357087638,0.9961722300897543,0.9961855799698842,0.996198336487466,0.9962105454357741,0.9962222479497366],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9968421555245685,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9960584623661753,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6386933757524468},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.351540722238117,3.4003051774350226,3.3080289320101066,3.1824229810358737,3.0221021716139376,2.827008742477085,2.596894006998448,2.3313938519246595,2.0300590958141296,1.6923172435171747,1.711492287515112,1.7198237779075027,1.7282280467424442,1.7364050827039723,1.7443657005835238,1.7521370818507118,1.7597320704187063,1.7671448853266567,1.7744012096992723,1.7815059770848622],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9973247472598528,0.9973095955020573,0.9971826512881856,0.9970203199791425,0.9968111974646976,0.9965394111173037,0.9961794666380038,0.995688372357251,0.9949881056164803,0.9938790612742994,0.9937186851488296,0.9937836834421123,0.9938418356947358,0.9939014793042934,0.9939544441768612,0.9940084075105452,0.9940633742684055,0.9941095128553272,0.9941553435500727,0.9941981694788317],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9955278454093984,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9937186851488296,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5035862628717135}}},{"q":0.1,"tax_timing":"december","policy":"displacement_cohorts","receipt_schedule_supported":false,"max_collection_gap":0.28561934578007764,"first_collection_gap_month":"0004-12","max_cash_error":4.3655745685100555e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":15,"displaced_debt":45},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.050229338126088,4.170246354524111,4.10942412040154,4.01092096505773,3.8717534128027267,3.6660292208692424,3.4153274151631026,3.1204802109643945,2.7819188409723883,2.400176120131117,2.4275419544014762,2.4401701871646218,2.4526345800946814,2.464542960667662,2.475950422719557,2.486894545895466,2.4974094870497625,2.5075260680225044,2.5172721866909216,2.526673160281239],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9890233539956834,0.9891216387855383,0.9887561914047586,0.9882826182757337,0.9876690195965103,0.9799085506997721,0.9697192782033359,0.9563999715316746,0.9386061310831478,0.9140342294198802,0.9158654971303282,0.9166991266307678,0.9175149891741511,0.9182880869532143,0.9190228965493132,0.9197226155988332,0.9203901096053253,0.9210279354844106,0.9216383828998213,0.9222235085979353],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9505303562295148,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9140342294198802,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5860977338164064},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3155796432595084,3.3636136770824416,3.245979605598588,2.8800994350657176,2.7322070551940305,2.5089542195293744,2.244709688190804,1.9564247621753474,1.6532089086843058,1.2628835677735673,1.2508829934980707,1.2581494025134674,1.304412647172356,1.3255844229545957,1.333953942079823,1.3420801472267896,1.3500188975328782,1.3577812597739747,1.365378506531929,1.372820931877723],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9866237362992631,0.9865479775102866,0.9784783070719194,0.902305468956328,0.901192094691818,0.8844230733645648,0.8610800802469608,0.8355471065009672,0.8102834068386617,0.7416774482714138,0.7262818609475967,0.7270095713361935,0.7501208316881355,0.7587517060625376,0.7600983260642811,0.761378184227074,0.7626185617497626,0.7638215054836837,0.7649895248139448,0.7661248825717754],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.8459787461298112,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.7262818609475967,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.37222778081270697}}},{"q":0.15,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"owners_only","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":3.433342499192804e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.15,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"per_capita","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":4.501998773775995e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.092802845522742,4.2136845912517735,4.15368315102076,4.0559601196009085,3.9175349709922207,3.7385987287531575,3.5193411592050157,3.260065376048558,2.9611784921476874,2.6231774048745904,2.647806655717914,2.6591720652047446,2.6703900188417977,2.6811075613574804,2.6913742772041855,2.701223988062504,2.710687435101371,2.7197923579768384,2.7285638647784145,2.7370247410097],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9994193561875693,0.9994245552670569,0.9994052237918198,0.9993801726690092,0.999347714459437,0.9993059632710395,0.9992520639467296,0.999181607333646,0.9990874812831956,0.9989575005709193,0.9989671876307424,0.998971597373127,0.9989759131316694,0.9989800026726972,0.9989838896764789,0.9989875910579064,0.9989911219749509,0.9989944959532132,0.9989977251045808,0.9990008203088534],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9991647799999391,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9989575005709193,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6405522992668605},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.358153150656163,3.4070519138101045,3.314903152381358,3.1894183686287096,3.029212867793469,2.834229303490292,2.6042193657041537,2.3388192838367274,2.0375801888873895,1.7000020935209794,1.719573148256749,1.7278441062889027,1.7361991898817781,1.744322046792424,1.752237988150299,1.7599609378562686,1.7675038158488157,1.774878394182129,1.7820954302792194,1.789164775680168],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9992924209500587,0.9992884134534118,0.9992548379093522,0.9992119028132751,0.9991565918858732,0.9990847069672674,0.9989895050564822,0.9988596152634949,0.9986744013329737,0.9983922880567325,0.9984105568970272,0.998418153312613,0.9984257536244983,0.9984330729960476,0.9984401407313263,0.9984469749772303,0.9984535923112985,0.9984600077042851,0.9984662347184257,0.9984722856714249],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9988316550905371,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9983922880567325,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5058730592209031}}},{"q":0.15,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"displacement_cohorts","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":4.547473508864641e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":1},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.08329148021632,4.2039800363995194,4.143795222257799,4.045897903021913,3.907306893700386,3.7282126210825632,3.5088043097685215,3.24938458058151,2.9503600969680663,2.6122273456562723,2.6368565964995954,2.6482220059864265,2.6594399596234797,2.670157502139163,2.6804242179858675,2.690273928844186,2.699737375883053,2.7088422987585203,2.717613805560096,2.726074681791382],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9970967809378457,0.9971227763352841,0.9970261189590988,0.9969008633450461,0.9967385722971858,0.9965298163551972,0.9962603197336477,0.9959080366682312,0.9954374064159779,0.9947875028545973,0.9948359381537115,0.9948579868656356,0.9948795656583481,0.994900013363487,0.9949194483823953,0.9949379552895319,0.9949556098747553,0.9949724797660663,0.9949886255229045,0.9950041015442672],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9958238999996962,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9947875028545973,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6378784101138174},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3486417853497406,3.397347358957851,3.3050152236183963,3.179356152049715,3.018984790501633,2.8238431958196983,2.593682516267659,2.32813848836968,2.026761793707769,1.6890377554715348,1.7038865814351227,1.7168703955359068,1.7252491306634599,1.733371987574106,1.7412879289319805,1.7490108786379504,1.7565537566304974,1.7639283349638109,1.771145371060901,1.77821471646185],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9964621047502933,0.9964420672670589,0.9962741895467615,0.9960595140663766,0.9957829594293666,0.9954235348363367,0.9949475252824119,0.9942980763174751,0.9933720066648696,0.9919530544852373,0.9893026954884796,0.9920770997504804,0.9921287681224911,0.9921653649802381,0.992200703656631,0.9922348748861519,0.9922679615564926,0.992300038521426,0.9923311735921284,0.9923614283571258],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9940531589376866,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9893026954884796,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5026103789850707}}},{"q":0.15,"tax_timing":"december","policy":"owners_only","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":3.979039320256561e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.15,"tax_timing":"december","policy":"per_capita","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":4.001776687800884e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.08169528223237,4.202351417332619,4.142135829368513,4.0442092611392795,3.905590417061444,3.7264696237745225,3.507036014966894,3.2475921287470744,2.9485445531403447,2.610389705960465,2.635018956803788,2.646384366290619,2.657602319927672,2.668319862443355,2.67858657829006,2.6884362891483784,2.6978997361872454,2.7070046590627124,2.7157761658642885,2.724237042095574],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9967070061987051,0.9967364916356616,0.9966268574214278,0.9964847854827202,0.9963007058789531,0.9960639231876598,0.9957582450127668,0.9953586658126166,0.9948248505991611,0.9940876935492631,0.9941426315805766,0.9941676404655897,0.9941921163418912,0.994215309275263,0.994237353563146,0.9942583451346317,0.9942783699548263,0.9942975047311989,0.9943158181536612,0.9943333719246047],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9952632332868527,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9940876935492631,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6374296778511095},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3470455873657907,3.39571873989095,3.3033558307291098,3.177667510167081,3.017268313862692,2.8221001985116576,2.5919142214660327,2.3263460365352446,2.024946249880047,1.6871688759008985,1.7064492800546136,1.7148185122164405,1.7232562625387016,1.7314373058716512,1.7394058370017087,1.7471603076522175,1.7547161169346897,1.7620906952680033,1.7693077313650942,1.7763770767660425],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.995987120889779,0.9959643932530859,0.9957739769322781,0.9955304799687138,0.9952167961970462,0.9948091166759557,0.9942691999570056,0.9935325585358767,0.9924821584247204,0.990855482336508,0.9907906376318185,0.9908914386441469,0.990982741289319,0.991057971881009,0.9911282716328775,0.9911850237429009,0.9912298885751496,0.9912662720668632,0.991301587209342,0.9913359038597436],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9933535299898161,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9907906376318185,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5020542527136288}}},{"q":0.15,"tax_timing":"december","policy":"displacement_cohorts","receipt_schedule_supported":false,"max_collection_gap":0.26910668830939,"first_collection_gap_month":"0005-12","max_cash_error":4.3655745685100555e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":15,"displaced_debt":42},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.027753663764459,4.147314166803748,4.086058613996561,3.9871436107137668,3.8475841240465,3.6660292208692424,3.4153274151631026,3.120480210964394,2.7819188409723883,2.4001761201311176,2.4275419544014767,2.4401701871646218,2.452634580094681,2.4645429606676617,2.475950422719557,2.4868945458954657,2.497409487049762,2.507526068022504,2.517272186690921,2.526673160281239],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9835350309935253,0.9836824581783074,0.983134287107138,0.9824239274136005,0.9815035293947655,0.9799085506997721,0.9697192782033359,0.9563999715316743,0.9386061310831478,0.9140342294198803,0.9158654971303283,0.9166991266307678,0.9175149891741509,0.9182880869532141,0.9190228965493132,0.9197226155988331,0.9203901096053251,0.9210279354844104,0.9216383828998211,0.9222235085979353],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9486932941379729,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9140342294198803,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5860977338164065},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.2931039688978796,3.3406814893620793,3.247278615357158,2.9083158849410067,2.71052444471119,2.530228842523229,2.2454511132402426,1.9565726506358196,1.6342856797144774,1.285069042241549,1.2334034329073367,1.2624967770589852,1.3184725221813482,1.3256563229066913,1.3340258420319189,1.3421520471788857,1.3500907974849738,1.3578531597260703,1.3654504064840247,1.372892831829819],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9799356044488952,0.97982196626543,0.9788698846613914,0.911145391886428,0.8940402951522219,0.8919225196702957,0.8613644940152206,0.835610266494452,0.8010086089849148,0.7547067302353181,0.7161329598430394,0.7295216600424002,0.7582061604819331,0.7587928608998862,0.7601392952698197,0.7614189739333267,0.762659177653849,0.7638619528895221,0.7650298086692455,0.7661650075007281],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.8457427765270564,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.7161329598430394,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.36702635263589944}}},{"q":0.2,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"owners_only","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":3.54702933691442e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.2,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"per_capita","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":4.092726157978177e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.092010231747207,4.212875878347419,4.152859156957181,4.055121601552659,3.9166826312179017,3.7377332197806075,3.5184630884186414,3.2591753097596374,2.9602769592160523,2.6222648999397307,2.6468941507830537,2.658259560269885,2.669477513906938,2.6801950564226207,2.690461772269326,2.7003114831276442,2.7097749301665113,2.7188798530419787,2.7276513598435543,2.7361122360748404],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9992258082500923,0.9992327403560759,0.9992069650557599,0.999173563558679,0.9991302859459162,0.9990746176947192,0.9990027519289728,0.9989088097781949,0.9987833083775941,0.9986100007612259,0.9986229168409897,0.9986287964975027,0.9986345508422261,0.9986400035635964,0.9986451862353053,0.9986501214105419,0.9986548292999347,0.9986593279376177,0.9986636334727744,0.9986677604118046],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9988863733332523,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9986100007612259,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6403294751707737},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.357360536880628,3.4062432009057497,3.314079158317778,3.18857985058046,3.0283605280191495,2.8333637945177426,2.6033412949177794,2.3379292175478072,2.036678655955755,1.6990895885861197,1.718660643321889,1.726931601354043,1.7352866849469182,1.7434095418575646,1.7513254832154392,1.7590484329214089,1.766591310913956,1.7739658892472692,1.7811829253443596,1.7882522707453088],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9990565612667449,0.9990512179378823,0.9990064505458031,0.9989492037510336,0.9988754558478311,0.9987796092896898,0.9986526734086432,0.9984794870179934,0.9982325351106319,0.9978563840756435,0.9978807425293694,0.9978908710834841,0.9979010048326643,0.9979107639947303,0.9979201876417684,0.9979292999696405,0.9979381230817314,0.9979466769390468,0.9979549796245676,0.9979630475619004],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9984422067873827,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9978563840756435,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5056015232829705}}},{"q":0.2,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"displacement_cohorts","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":5.729816621169448e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.079328411338643,4.199936471877747,4.139675251939898,4.041705312780666,3.9030451948287874,3.723885076219816,3.504413955836648,3.244934249136907,2.9458524323098914,2.6076648209819733,2.632294071825296,2.6436594813121275,2.6548774349491806,2.6655949774648633,2.6758616933115684,2.6857114041698864,2.695174851208754,2.7042797740842213,2.7130512808857965,2.7215121571170826],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9961290412504608,0.9961637017803788,0.9960348252787984,0.995867817793395,0.995651429729581,0.9953730884735964,0.9950137596448633,0.9945440488909751,0.9939165418879706,0.9930500038061298,0.9931145842049486,0.9931439824875143,0.9931727542111309,0.9932000178179826,0.9932259311765271,0.9932506070527091,0.9932741464996738,0.9932966396880883,0.9933181673638726,0.9933388020590228],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9944318666662616,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9930500038061298,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6367642896333828},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.344678716472065,3.393303794436078,3.3008952533004954,3.1751635618084673,3.014723091630035,2.8195156509569506,2.589292162335786,2.3236881569250762,2.0222541290495935,1.6844895096283623,1.7039707404779445,1.7123315223962856,1.7206866059891606,1.728809462899807,1.7367254042576814,1.7444483539636515,1.7519912319561985,1.7593658102895118,1.7665828463866022,1.773652191787551],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9952828063337245,0.9952560896894116,0.9950322527290153,0.9947460187551689,0.9943772792391554,0.9938980464484488,0.9932633670432158,0.9923974350899667,0.9911626755531594,0.9892819203782172,0.9893515595201707,0.9894543554174201,0.9895050241633213,0.989553819973651,0.9896009382088415,0.9896464998482029,0.989690615408657,0.9897333846952349,0.9897748981228381,0.9898152378095012],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9922090563274152,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9892819203782172,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5012569482760478}}},{"q":0.2,"tax_timing":"december","policy":"owners_only","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":4.411049303598702e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.2,"tax_timing":"december","policy":"per_capita","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":4.1382008930668235e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.077200147360044,4.197764979788546,4.137462728087517,4.0394537902704855,3.9007565593101985,3.7215610798090943,3.502056229434479,3.24254431335766,2.943431707206262,2.6052146347208964,2.6298438855642194,2.64120929505105,2.6524272486881038,2.6631447912037864,2.6734115070504916,2.68326121790881,2.6927246649476766,2.7018295878231444,2.71060109462472,2.719061970856006],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9956093415982734,0.9956486555142151,0.9955024765619035,0.9953130473102932,0.9950676078386042,0.9947518975835462,0.994344326683689,0.9938115544168225,0.9930998007988815,0.9921169247323508,0.9921901754407688,0.9922235206207861,0.9922561551225216,0.9922870790336841,0.9923164714175281,0.9923444601795091,0.9923711599397684,0.9923966729749322,0.9924210908715484,0.9924444958994731],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9936843110491369,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9921169247323508,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6361659799497723},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3425504524934646,3.391132302346877,3.298682729448114,3.1729120392982884,3.012434456111447,2.81719165454623,2.5869344359336184,2.3212982211458293,2.0198334039459644,1.6820093298750485,1.701377792170125,1.709765358544555,1.718194911441718,1.7263592766387297,1.7342752179966046,1.7419981677025742,1.7495410456951213,1.7569156240284347,1.764132660125525,1.7712020055264743],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9946494945197053,0.9946191910041146,0.9943653025763709,0.994040639958285,0.9936223949293951,0.9930788222346075,0.9923589332760078,0.9913767447145021,0.9899762112329609,0.9878253384433241,0.9878460539436038,0.9879715222355276,0.9880721401827098,0.988151357049698,0.9882048011932812,0.9882564797586187,0.9883065181001996,0.9883550294224843,0.9884021162791221,0.9884478718129915],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9911560697012739,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9878253384433241,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.500518916173612}}},{"q":0.2,"tax_timing":"december","policy":"displacement_cohorts","receipt_schedule_supported":false,"max_collection_gap":0.2525979662023599,"first_collection_gap_month":"0005-12","max_cash_error":5.2523319027386606e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":14,"displaced_debt":42},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.005277989402829,4.1243819790833856,4.06269310759158,3.9633662563698038,3.823414835290274,3.643024376362253,3.415327415163102,3.120480210964394,2.7819188409723883,2.400176120131117,2.4275419544014762,2.4401701871646218,2.4526345800946814,2.4645429606676617,2.475950422719557,2.4868945458954657,2.4974094870497625,2.507526068022504,2.5172721866909216,2.5266731602812396],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9780467079913671,0.9782432775710765,0.9775123828095172,0.9765652365514674,0.9753380391930209,0.9737594879177323,0.9697192782033358,0.9563999715316743,0.9386061310831478,0.9140342294198802,0.9158654971303282,0.9166991266307678,0.9175149891741511,0.9182880869532141,0.9190228965493132,0.9197226155988331,0.9203901096053253,0.9210279354844104,0.9216383828998213,0.9222235085979354],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9464941576498394,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9140342294198802,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5860977338164064},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.27062829453625,3.317749301641717,3.2239131089521775,2.980628739948606,2.688459938476371,2.508275568167974,2.2705409993170407,1.9567186585088883,1.6309454791675968,1.2909838729081247,1.2335327113007686,1.262558277644913,1.318531505258444,1.3257162874100434,1.334086420450931,1.3422132283800206,1.3501525615404804,1.3579154885064302,1.3655132831955679,1.372956240893312],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9732474725985268,0.9730959550205736,0.9718265128818552,0.9338002640602125,0.8867625309892548,0.8841838442394891,0.8709890798714919,0.8356726233293416,0.7993714843212177,0.7581804443825988,0.7162080208620556,0.7295571975664199,0.7582400795296689,0.7588271840017827,0.760173813369309,0.7614536827634403,0.7626940678433599,0.7638970160210146,0.7650650370146861,0.766200393952227],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.8454788885903334,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.7162080208620556,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.36706482226874626}}},{"q":0.25,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"owners_only","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":4.4792614062316716e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.25,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"per_capita","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":2.8421709430404007e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.091217617971672,4.212067165443065,4.1520351628936005,4.0542830835044095,3.915830291443582,3.736867710808059,3.5175850176322667,3.2582852434707172,2.959375426284417,2.6213523950048714,2.645981645848194,2.657347055335025,2.6685650089720783,2.679282551487761,2.689549267334466,2.699398978192784,2.7088624252316515,2.717967348107119,2.7267388549086946,2.7351997311399807],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9990322603126155,0.9990409254450948,0.9990087063196997,0.9989669544483488,0.9989128574323952,0.9988432721183993,0.998753439911216,0.9986360122227438,0.9984791354719926,0.9982625009515326,0.9982786460512372,0.9982859956218785,0.9982931885527826,0.9983000044544955,0.9983064827941317,0.9983126517631772,0.9983185366249184,0.9983241599220222,0.9983295418409681,0.9983347005147558],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9986079666665654,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9982625009515326,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6401066510746868},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3565679231050924,3.4054344880013954,3.3132551642541976,3.1877413325322106,3.0275081882448296,2.832498285545193,2.6024632241314047,2.3370391512588866,2.0357771230241197,1.69817708365126,1.7177481383870288,1.7260190964191828,1.7343741800120585,1.7424970369227044,1.7504129782805793,1.7581359279865487,1.7656788059790962,1.7730533843124092,1.7802704204095,1.7873397658104488],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9988207015834311,0.998814022422353,0.9987580631822538,0.998686504688792,0.9985943198097887,0.9984745116121122,0.9983158417608039,0.9980993587724918,0.9977906688882898,0.9973204800945543,0.9973509281617117,0.9973635888543548,0.9973762560408305,0.9973884549934127,0.9974002345522104,0.9974116249620505,0.9974226538521643,0.9974333461738085,0.9974437245307096,0.9974538094523753],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9980527584842285,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9973204800945543,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5053299873450379}}},{"q":0.25,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"displacement_cohorts","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":4.297362465877086e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.075365342460968,4.195892907355976,4.135555281621998,4.037512722539418,3.898783495957189,3.719557531357069,3.5000236019047755,3.2404839176923033,2.9413447676517155,2.6031022963076738,2.6277315471509968,2.639096956637828,2.650314910274881,2.6610324527905638,2.671299168637269,2.6811488794955873,2.6906123265344544,2.6997172494099217,2.7084887562114974,2.7169496324427835],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9951613015630759,0.9952046272254739,0.9950435315984981,0.9948347722417437,0.9945642871619761,0.9942163605919956,0.9937671995560791,0.9931800611137189,0.9923956773599631,0.9913125047576622,0.9913932302561858,0.9914299781093929,0.9914659427639135,0.9915000222724781,0.9915324139706588,0.9915632588158865,0.9915926831245923,0.9916207996101104,0.9916477092048408,0.9916735025737785],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9930398333328271,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9913125047576622,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6356501691529481},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3407156475943887,3.3892602299143055,3.2967752829825945,3.170970971567219,3.010461392758437,2.8151881060942037,2.5849018084039135,2.3192378254804726,2.017746464391418,1.6799269849540628,1.6994367361453844,1.7077689977219863,1.7161240813148613,1.7242469382255077,1.7321628795833823,1.7398858292893524,1.747428707281899,1.7548032856152125,1.7620203217123034,1.7690896671132519],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9941035079171555,0.9940701121117644,0.9937903159112691,0.9934325234439612,0.9929715990489444,0.9923725580605612,0.99157920880402,0.9904967938624583,0.9889533444414492,0.9866024004727713,0.9867190470299437,0.9868179442717752,0.9868812802041517,0.9869422749670637,0.987001172761052,0.9870581248102536,0.987113269260821,0.9871667308690435,0.9872186226535479,0.9872690472618767],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9902624427303536,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9866024004727713,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.4998992685863844}}},{"q":0.25,"tax_timing":"december","policy":"owners_only","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":3.433342499192804e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.25,"tax_timing":"december","policy":"per_capita","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":3.1377567211166024e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.072705012487718,4.193178542244474,4.132789626806521,4.034698319401694,3.8959227015589537,3.716652535843668,3.497076443902065,3.2374964979682446,2.938318861272179,2.600039563481328,2.6246688143246506,2.636034223811482,2.647252177448535,2.6579697199642176,2.6682364358109227,2.6780861466692407,2.687549593708108,2.6966545165835756,2.7054260233851513,2.7138868996164374],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9945116769978419,0.9945608193927691,0.9943780957023794,0.9941413091378669,0.9938345097982553,0.9934398719794332,0.9929304083546115,0.992264443021028,0.9913747509986018,0.9901461559154385,0.9902377193009608,0.9902794007759826,0.9903201939031518,0.990358848792105,0.99039558927191,0.9904305752243859,0.9904639499247105,0.990495841218665,0.9905263635894354,0.9905556198743413],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9921053888114211,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9901461559154385,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.634902282048435},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.338055317621139,3.3865458648028053,3.294009628167118,3.1681565684294952,3.0076005983602014,2.812283110580802,2.5819546504012028,2.316250405756414,2.0147205580118817,1.6768497838491991,1.6962906795962505,1.704668276944309,1.713061348488515,1.7211842053991613,1.729100146757036,1.736823096463006,1.744365974455553,1.751740552788866,1.758957588885957,1.7660269342869055],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9933118681496317,0.9932739887551435,0.9929566282204637,0.9925507999478561,0.9920279936617438,0.9913485277932593,0.9904486665950094,0.9892209308931276,0.987470264041201,0.9847951945501406,0.9848923983209693,0.9850262224946086,0.9851200126329444,0.9851891963121225,0.9852560014916015,0.9853205996982737,0.9853831476252497,0.9854437867781053,0.9855026453489029,0.9855598397662393],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9889523085044054,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9847951945501406,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.4989835796335954}}},{"q":0.25,"tax_timing":"december","policy":"displacement_cohorts","receipt_schedule_supported":false,"max_collection_gap":0.23609028387131809,"first_collection_gap_month":"0006-12","max_cash_error":5.616129783447832e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":13,"displaced_debt":41},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.9828023150411997,4.101449791363024,4.0393276011866,3.9395889020258408,3.7992455465340473,3.6184816565351148,3.397480733253766,3.1204802109643945,2.7819188409723883,2.4001761201311176,2.427541954401476,2.4401701871646218,2.452634580094681,2.464542960667662,2.475950422719557,2.4868945458954657,2.4974094870497625,2.507526068022504,2.517272186690921,2.526673160281239],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9725583849892088,0.9728040969638458,0.9718904785118965,0.9707065456893343,0.969172548991276,0.9671993598971652,0.9646520417730565,0.9563999715316746,0.9386061310831478,0.9140342294198803,0.9158654971303279,0.9166991266307678,0.9175149891741509,0.9182880869532143,0.9190228965493132,0.9197226155988331,0.9203901096053253,0.9210279354844104,0.9216383828998211,0.9222235085979353],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9439899266473771,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9140342294198803,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5860977338164065},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.248152620174621,3.2948171139213542,3.2005476025471973,3.052423314200698,2.6794586762230543,2.4860113959039856,2.2732083513586367,1.9660359823870306,1.631069089947153,1.2932813953608506,1.233644072616907,1.2626078854963934,1.3185746404363712,1.3257594225879705,1.334129555628858,1.3422563635579474,1.3501956967184072,1.3579586236843568,1.3655564183734943,1.3729993760712387],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9665593407481589,0.9663699437757169,0.964783141102319,0.9562927642150121,0.8837935516179748,0.8763355752251075,0.8720122873366299,0.8396518527672566,0.799432069382824,0.7595297537200291,0.7162726789510558,0.7295858629878458,0.7582648850201797,0.7588518741605359,0.7601983921613515,0.7614781538678778,0.7627184346780846,0.7639212817680235,0.7650892046422757,0.766224466234603],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.8451853562047443,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.7162726789510558,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.36709796028068664}}},{"q":0.3,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"owners_only","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":4.320099833421409e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.3,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"per_capita","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":3.774403012357652e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.0904250041961365,4.21125845253871,4.15121116883002,4.053444565456159,3.914977951669262,3.7360022018355084,3.5167069468458916,3.257395177181796,2.958473893352782,2.620439890070011,2.6450691409133342,2.6564345504001654,2.6676525040372185,2.6783700465529012,2.6886367623996064,2.698486473257925,2.707949920296792,2.717054843172259,2.725826349973835,2.7342872262051205],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9988387123751383,0.9988491105341136,0.9988104475836396,0.9987603453380183,0.9986954289188743,0.9986119265420788,0.998504127893459,0.9983632146672924,0.9981749625663912,0.997915001141839,0.9979343752614847,0.9979431947462543,0.9979518262633392,0.9979600053453948,0.9979677793529581,0.9979751821158128,0.9979822439499021,0.9979889919064266,0.9979954502091618,0.9980016406177068],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9983295599998785,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.997915001141839,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6398838269785998},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3557753093295566,3.40462577509704,3.312431170190617,3.186902814483961,3.0266558484705106,2.8316327765726435,2.6015851533450305,2.336149084969966,2.0348755900924846,1.6972645787164,1.716835633452169,1.7251065914843229,1.7334616750771987,1.7415845319878445,1.7495004733457193,1.7572234230516892,1.7647663010442363,1.7721408793775497,1.77935791547464,1.786427260875589],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9985848419001171,0.9985768269068233,0.9985096758187043,0.9984238056265505,0.9983131837717468,0.9981694139345346,0.9979790101129649,0.9977192305269901,0.9973488026659478,0.9967845761134652,0.996821113794054,0.9968363066252258,0.9968515072489965,0.9968661459920951,0.9968802814626524,0.9968939499544609,0.9969071846225971,0.9969200154085704,0.9969324694368514,0.9969445713428503],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9976633101810742,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9967845761134652,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5050584514071051}}},{"q":0.3,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"displacement_cohorts","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":5.1159076974727213e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.071402273583292,4.191849342834202,4.131435311304097,4.0333201322981695,3.8945217970855905,3.715229986494321,3.4956332479729024,3.2360335862476997,2.9368371029935405,2.5985397716333747,2.623169022476698,2.634534431963529,2.6457523856005816,2.6564699281162647,2.6667366439629703,2.6765863548212883,2.6860498018601553,2.6951547247356227,2.7039262315371984,2.712387107768484],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9941935618756912,0.9942455526705684,0.9940522379181976,0.9938017266900923,0.9934771445943713,0.9930596327103945,0.9925206394672949,0.9918160733364627,0.9908748128319559,0.9895750057091948,0.9896718763074231,0.9897159737312715,0.9897591313166962,0.9898000267269739,0.9898388967647909,0.9898759105790639,0.9899112197495108,0.9899449595321325,0.989977251045809,0.9900082030885342],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9916477999993925,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9895750057091948,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6345360486725135},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.336752578716712,3.3852166653925337,3.2926553126646936,3.1667783813259707,3.006199693886839,2.810860561231456,2.580511454472041,2.31478749403587,2.0132387997332426,1.6753644602797637,1.6948917878271057,1.7032064730476866,1.7115615566405622,1.7196844135512082,1.727600354909083,1.7353233046150525,1.7428661826076,1.7502407609409132,1.7574577970380036,1.7645271424389526],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9929242095005865,0.9928841345341175,0.9925483790935228,0.9921190281327532,0.9915659188587334,0.9908470696726733,0.9898950505648241,0.9885961526349503,0.9867440133297392,0.9839228805673256,0.984080180293672,0.9841815331261299,0.984257536244982,0.9843307299604762,0.9844014073132624,0.9844697497723038,0.9845359231129853,0.9846000770428522,0.984662347184257,0.984722856714252],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9883155881847979,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9839228805673256,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.49854158889672107}}},{"q":0.3,"tax_timing":"december","policy":"owners_only","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":3.842615114990622e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.3,"tax_timing":"december","policy":"per_capita","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":4.9112713895738125e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.068209877615391,4.188592104700401,4.128116525525525,4.029942848532901,3.891088843807708,3.71174399187824,3.4920966583696496,3.2324486825788292,2.9332060153380968,2.594864492241759,2.619493743085082,2.6308591525719134,2.6420771062089665,2.652794648724649,2.6630613645713543,2.6729110754296728,2.68237452246854,2.691479445344007,2.7002509521455833,2.7087118283768685],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.99341401239741,0.9934729832713229,0.9932537148428552,0.9929695709654403,0.9926014117579063,0.9921278463753196,0.9915164900255337,0.9907173316252337,0.9896497011983223,0.988175387098526,0.9882852631611531,0.9883352809311793,0.9883842326837823,0.988430618550526,0.988474707126292,0.9885166902692634,0.9885567399096528,0.988595009462398,0.9886316363073226,0.9886667438492094],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9905264665737054,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.988175387098526,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6336385841470976},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.333560182748813,3.3819594272587317,3.289336526886122,3.163401097560703,3.0027667406089567,2.8073745666153744,2.576974864868788,2.3112025903669986,2.009607712077799,1.671689180888148,1.6911769087539217,1.699531193656071,1.7078862772489467,1.7160091341595929,1.7239250755174673,1.7316480252234372,1.7391909032159842,1.7465654815492977,1.753782517646388,1.7608518630473369],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9919742417795581,0.9919287865061719,0.9915479538645564,0.9910609599374275,0.9904335923940927,0.9896182333519112,0.9885383999140114,0.987065117071753,0.9849643168494411,0.9817644299306895,0.9819232644985965,0.9820578081617487,0.9821440151595332,0.9822270355745472,0.9823072017899217,0.9823847196379282,0.9824597771502994,0.9825325441337265,0.9826031744186831,0.982671807719487],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9867461425490842,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9817644299306895,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.4974479285792344}}},{"q":0.3,"tax_timing":"december","policy":"displacement_cohorts","receipt_schedule_supported":false,"max_collection_gap":0.2127953994615709,"first_collection_gap_month":"0006-12","max_cash_error":4.7066350816749036e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":12,"displaced_debt":32},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.96032664067957,4.07851760364266,4.01596209478162,3.9158115476818764,3.7750762577778207,3.5939389367079766,3.3725818055916905,3.111301113232866,2.7819188409723883,2.4001761201311176,2.4275419544014767,2.440170187164622,2.452634580094681,2.464542960667661,2.475950422719556,2.486894545895465,2.4974094870497625,2.5075260680225036,2.517272186690921,2.526673160281239],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9670700619870505,0.9673649163566147,0.9662685742142757,0.964847854827201,0.9630070587895312,0.9606392318765983,0.9575824501276676,0.953586658126169,0.9386061310831478,0.9140342294198803,0.9158654971303283,0.9166991266307679,0.9175149891741509,0.918288086953214,0.9190228965493129,0.919722615598833,0.9203901096053253,0.9210279354844103,0.9216383828998211,0.9222235085979353],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9412302297191986,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9140342294198803,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5860977338164065},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.2256769458129906,3.271884926200991,3.1771820961422175,3.0492697967096793,2.7020740548682225,2.4636059788432214,2.250847822965065,1.9914324711767564,1.6311756549237824,1.2877166765618404,1.2417271945793495,1.2626560285727961,1.3186177756142978,1.3255988125197287,1.3322133852884912,1.338687722070254,1.3450255517143386,1.3512291763404456,1.357316000583833,1.3706503942633936],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9598712088977903,0.9596439325308601,0.9577397693227829,0.9553047996871378,0.8912530157221842,0.8684375164790962,0.8634346945704937,0.8504981491001374,0.7994842998250019,0.7562616563716139,0.7209658635987519,0.7296136820030346,0.7582896905106904,0.758759942510481,0.7591065419690608,0.7594536206969849,0.7597978470076112,0.7601356229483142,0.7604722919993535,0.7649135790169693],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.8431136206777772,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.7209658635987519,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.36950327122164406}}},{"q":0.35,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"owners_only","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":4.433786671143025e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.35,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"per_capita","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":3.61524143954739e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.089632390420601,4.210449739634355,4.15038717476644,4.0526060474079095,3.914125611894942,3.735136692862959,3.5158288760595173,3.256505110892876,2.9575723604211475,2.6195273851351515,2.644156635978474,2.6555220454653057,2.666739999102359,2.6774575416180415,2.6877242574647466,2.697573968323065,2.707037415361932,2.7161423382373995,2.724913845038975,2.733374721270261],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9986451644376612,0.9986572956231325,0.9986121888475795,0.9985537362276881,0.9984780004053533,0.9983805809657587,0.9982548158757022,0.9980904171118413,0.9978707896607898,0.9975675013321454,0.997590104471732,0.99760039387063,0.9976104639738959,0.9976200062362939,0.9976290759117845,0.9976377124684483,0.9976459512748859,0.997653823890831,0.9976613585773555,0.997668580720658],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9980511533331916,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9975675013321454,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6396610028825129},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.354982695554022,3.403817062192686,3.311607176127037,3.1860642964357115,3.0258035086961907,2.830767267600094,2.600707082558656,2.3352590186810454,2.0339740571608496,1.69635207378154,1.7159231285173093,1.724194086549463,1.7325491701423386,1.7406720270529847,1.7485879684108596,1.756310918116829,1.7638537961093763,1.77122837444269,1.77844541053978,1.7855147559407292],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9983489822168035,0.998339631391294,0.9982612884551552,0.998161106564309,0.9980320477337045,0.997864316256957,0.9976421784651256,0.9973391022814885,0.9969069364436058,0.9962486721323759,0.9962912994263965,0.9963090243960967,0.9963267584571625,0.9963438369907778,0.9963603283730945,0.9963762749468708,0.9963917153930298,0.9964066846433323,0.9964212143429932,0.9964353332333254],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9972738618779199,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9962486721323759,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5047869154691724}}},{"q":0.35,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"displacement_cohorts","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":3.5925040720030665e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.067439204705615,4.1878057783124305,4.127315340986196,4.029127542056922,3.8902600982139925,3.710902441631574,3.4912428940410294,3.2315832548030965,2.932329438335365,2.5939772469590756,2.6186064978023986,2.62997190728923,2.641189860926283,2.6519074034419656,2.6621741192886708,2.672023830146989,2.681487277185856,2.6905922000613236,2.6993637068628997,2.707824583094185],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9932258221883062,0.9932864781156632,0.9930609442378971,0.9927686811384411,0.9923900020267665,0.9919029048287937,0.9912740793785105,0.9904520855592066,0.9893539483039486,0.9878375066607272,0.9879505223586602,0.9880019693531502,0.9880523198694792,0.9881000311814696,0.9881453795589226,0.9881885623422412,0.9882297563744293,0.9882691194541546,0.9883067928867775,0.9883429036032899],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9902557666659579,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9878375066607272,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6334219281920789},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3327895098390368,3.381173100870761,3.288535342346793,3.162585791084723,3.001937995015241,2.806533016368709,2.576121100540168,2.3103371625912668,2.0087311350750676,1.6708019356054644,1.6903429507268295,1.6986439483733873,1.7069990319662627,1.7151218888769089,1.7230378302347837,1.7307607799407534,1.7383036579333007,1.7456782362666137,1.7528952723637043,1.7599646177646533],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9917449110840177,0.9916981569564703,0.9913064422757768,0.9908055328215455,0.9901602386685222,0.9893215812847858,0.988210892325628,0.986695511407442,0.9845346822180292,0.9812433606618798,0.9814390556708987,0.9815451219804848,0.9816337922858123,0.9817191849538889,0.9818016418654728,0.9818813747343547,0.9819585769651494,0.9820334232166608,0.9821060717149666,0.9821766661666274],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9863686480217909,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9812433606618798,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.49718390920705774}}},{"q":0.35,"tax_timing":"december","policy":"owners_only","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":4.501998773775995e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.35,"tax_timing":"december","policy":"per_capita","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":3.9335645851679146e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.063714742743066,4.184005667156328,4.123443424244528,4.025187377664108,3.8862549860564624,3.7068354479128116,3.4871168728372344,3.2274008671894148,2.928093169404014,2.589689421002191,2.614318671845514,2.625684081332345,2.636902034969398,2.647619577485081,2.657886293331786,2.6677360041901044,2.6771994512289714,2.686304374104439,2.6950758809060145,2.7035367571373006],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9923163477969785,0.9923851471498767,0.992129333983331,0.9917978327930135,0.9913683137175572,0.9908158207712061,0.9901025716964558,0.9891702202294395,0.9879246513980426,0.9862046182816138,0.9863328070213453,0.9863911610863759,0.9864482714644127,0.9865023883089471,0.9865538249806741,0.9866028053141406,0.986649529894595,0.986694177706131,0.9867369090252096,0.9867778678240778],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9889475443359895,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9862046182816138,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6323748862457603},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3290650478764867,3.3773729897146594,3.2846634256051255,3.1586456266919107,2.997932882857711,2.8024660226499467,2.5719950793363733,2.3061547749775837,2.004494866143716,1.6665141096485798,1.6860312354538995,1.6943561224165031,1.702711206009378,1.7108340629200245,1.7187500042778994,1.726472953983869,1.734015831976416,1.7413904103097293,1.7486074464068202,1.755676791807769],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9906366154094843,0.9905835842572006,0.9901392795086491,0.9895711199269989,0.9888391911264414,0.987887938910563,0.9866281332330133,0.9849093032503786,0.9824583696576813,0.9787251682524712,0.9789356076197405,0.9790674428553737,0.979168017686122,0.9792648748369717,0.9793584020882423,0.9794488395775831,0.9795364066753495,0.9796213014893476,0.979703703488464,0.9797837756727352],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9845381193089264,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9787251682524712,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.49590797216999005}}},{"q":0.35,"tax_timing":"december","policy":"displacement_cohorts","receipt_schedule_supported":false,"max_collection_gap":0.18588300295003146,"first_collection_gap_month":"0007-12","max_cash_error":4.18367562815547e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":12,"displaced_debt":30},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.9378509663179404,4.055585415922297,3.99259658837664,3.8920341933379135,3.750906969021594,3.569396216880839,3.3476828779296155,3.0860620362857896,2.781918840972388,2.400176120131117,2.4275419544014762,2.4401701871646218,2.4526345800946814,2.4645429606676617,2.4759504227195563,2.486894545895465,2.4974094870497625,2.5075260680225036,2.5172721866909216,2.5266731602812396],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9615817389848922,0.9619257357493839,0.9606466699166551,0.958989163965068,0.9568415685877864,0.9540791038560315,0.9505128584822787,0.9458511011471972,0.9386061310831476,0.9140342294198802,0.9158654971303282,0.9166991266307678,0.9175149891741511,0.9182880869532141,0.9190228965493131,0.919722615598833,0.9203901096053253,0.9210279354844103,0.9216383828998213,0.9222235085979354],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9382177639760872,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9140342294198802,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5860977338164064},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.203201271451361,3.2489527384806287,3.1538165897372368,3.0254924423657155,2.726676123137878,2.461182357571351,2.2281477358806128,1.982454219696155,1.645465217429231,1.2674717933090274,1.2646743129694726,1.2627018785465836,1.2975057641461318,1.3162678156387466,1.3344626752561297,1.342592822274839,1.3505353333550383,1.3583012905103045,1.3659019797113638,1.3733477070463185],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.953183077047422,0.9529179212860036,0.9506963975432465,0.9478555996349939,0.8993677702008148,0.8675831738381447,0.8547268456619574,0.846663730219795,0.8064880095971466,0.7443720620062597,0.7342893126618469,0.7296401759708594,0.7461489314990081,0.7534189701211639,0.7603882065642938,0.761669030938419,0.7629102936245175,0.7641140494093431,0.7652828145477973,0.7664188579583758],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.8412326084225586,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.7296401759708594,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.37574475032636695}}},{"q":0.4,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"owners_only","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":3.979039320256561e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.4,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"per_capita","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":3.979039320256561e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.088839776645066,4.209641026730001,4.1495631807028595,4.05176752935966,3.913273272120623,3.7342711838904092,3.514950805273142,3.255615044603955,2.9566708274895124,2.6186148802002918,2.6432441310436148,2.654609540530446,2.665827494167499,2.6765450366831818,2.686811752529887,2.696661463388205,2.7061249104270724,2.7152298333025393,2.7240013401041154,2.732462216335401],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9984516165001843,0.9984654807121516,0.9984139301115194,0.9983471271173578,0.9982605718918325,0.9981492353894384,0.9980055038579452,0.9978176195563899,0.9975666167551883,0.9972200015224519,0.9972458336819796,0.9972575929950058,0.9972691016844525,0.9972800071271931,0.9972903724706109,0.9973002428210838,0.9973096585998696,0.9973186558752354,0.9973272669455492,0.9973355208236092],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9977727466665046,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9972200015224519,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6394381787864261},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.354190081778487,3.4030083492883314,3.310783182063457,3.185225778387462,3.024951168921871,2.829901758627545,2.5998290117722815,2.3343689523921247,2.0330725242292145,1.6954395688466803,1.7150106235824494,1.7232815816146032,1.7316366652074788,1.739759522118125,1.747675463476,1.755398413181969,1.7629412911745166,1.77031586950783,1.7775329056049207,1.7846022510058694],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9981131225334898,0.9981024358757645,0.998012901091606,0.9978984075020675,0.9977509116956622,0.9975592185793797,0.9973053468172866,0.9969589740359869,0.9964650702212637,0.9957127681512868,0.9957614850587388,0.9957817421669678,0.9958020096653286,0.9958215279894603,0.9958403752835367,0.9958585999392808,0.9958762461634628,0.995893353878094,0.9959099592491355,0.9959260951238006],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9968844135747656,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9957127681512868,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5045153795312398}}},{"q":0.4,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"displacement_cohorts","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":4.501998773775995e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.06347613582794,4.183762213790658,4.123195370668295,4.0249349518156725,3.8859983993423937,3.706574896768826,3.4868525401091564,3.2271329233584938,2.9278217736771897,2.5894147222847765,2.6140439731280996,2.6254093826149307,2.636627336251984,2.6473448787676666,2.6576115946143717,2.6674613054726897,2.676924752511557,2.686029675387024,2.6948011821886,2.703262058419886],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9922580825009214,0.9923274035607579,0.9920696505575967,0.9917356355867893,0.9913028594591615,0.9907461769471928,0.9900275192897263,0.9890880977819506,0.9878330837759413,0.9861000076122598,0.9862291684098974,0.9862879649750289,0.986345508422262,0.9864000356359653,0.9864518623530545,0.9865012141054184,0.9865482929993479,0.9865932793761766,0.9866363347277456,0.9866776041180457],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9888637333325233,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9861000076122598,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6323078077116443},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.32882644096136,3.3771295363489884,3.284415372028892,3.1583932008434754,2.9976762961436423,2.8022054715059617,2.571730746608295,2.305886831146663,2.004223470416892,1.6662394109311651,1.6858104656669344,1.694081423699088,1.7024365072919636,1.7105593642026098,1.7184753055604842,1.726198255266454,1.7337411332590014,1.7411157115923146,1.748332747689405,1.7554020930903538],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9905656126674487,0.9905121793788232,0.9900645054580305,0.9894920375103379,0.988754558478311,0.987796092896898,0.9865267340864319,0.9847948701799336,0.982325351106319,0.978563840756434,0.9788074252936944,0.9789087108348398,0.9790100483266426,0.9791076399473017,0.9792018764176831,0.9792929996964053,0.9793812308173137,0.9794667693904696,0.979549796245676,0.9796304756190025],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9844220678738281,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.978563840756434,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.49582622951739436}}},{"q":0.4,"tax_timing":"december","policy":"owners_only","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":3.524291969370097e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.4,"tax_timing":"december","policy":"per_capita","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":2.7057467377744615e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.05921960787074,4.1794192296122565,4.118770322963533,4.0204319067953165,3.8814211283052176,3.7019269039473848,3.48213708730482,3.2223530517999985,2.9229803234699308,2.5845143497626224,2.609143600605945,2.6205090100927766,2.6317269637298297,2.6424445062455124,2.652711222092217,2.6625609329505355,2.672024379989403,2.68112930286487,2.6899008096664456,2.6983616858977317],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9912186831965468,0.9912973110284307,0.991004953123807,0.9906260946205871,0.9901352156772083,0.989503795167093,0.9886886533673782,0.9876231088336448,0.9861996015977629,0.9842338494647015,0.9843803508815373,0.9844470412415726,0.9845123102450432,0.9845741580673683,0.984632942835056,0.9846889203590177,0.9847423198795371,0.9847933459498639,0.9848421817430966,0.984888991798946],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9873686220982738,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9842338494647015,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6311111883444231},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3245699130041615,3.3727865521705875,3.27999032432413,3.1538901558231176,2.9930990251064653,2.7975574786845194,2.567015293803958,2.3011069595881684,1.9993820202096333,1.6613390384090114,1.6808716894280495,1.6891810511769343,1.6975361347698095,1.7056589916804559,1.7135749330383305,1.7212978827443002,1.7288407607368477,1.7362153390701607,1.7434323751672514,1.7505017205682],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9892989890394108,0.9892383820082294,0.988730605152742,0.98808127991657,0.9872447898587899,0.9861576444692151,0.9847178665520152,0.9827534894290041,0.9799524224659214,0.9756859065742529,0.9759398960233905,0.9760770775489984,0.9761920202127108,0.9763027140993962,0.9764096023865625,0.9765129595172376,0.9766130362003995,0.9767100588449686,0.9768042325582443,0.9768957436259829],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9823297906396055,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9756859065742529,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.4943680157607456}}},{"q":0.4,"tax_timing":"december","policy":"displacement_cohorts","receipt_schedule_supported":false,"max_collection_gap":0.16455377530794213,"first_collection_gap_month":"0008-12","max_cash_error":4.2518877307884395e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":11,"displaced_debt":29},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.9153752919563107,4.032653228201935,3.9692310819716594,3.8682568389939505,3.7267376802653684,3.544853497053701,3.3227839502675405,3.0608229593387133,2.7593692535792846,2.400176120131117,2.427541954401476,2.4401701871646218,2.452634580094681,2.464542960667662,2.4759504227195563,2.4868945458954657,2.497409487049762,2.5075260680225036,2.517272186690921,2.526673160281239],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9560934159827339,0.9564865551421532,0.9550247656190343,0.9531304731029349,0.9506760783860417,0.9475189758354646,0.94344326683689,0.9381155441682252,0.9309980079888147,0.9140342294198802,0.9158654971303279,0.9166991266307678,0.9175149891741509,0.9182880869532143,0.9190228965493131,0.9197226155988331,0.9203901096053251,0.9210279354844103,0.9216383828998211,0.9222235085979353],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9348503891508357,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9140342294198802,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5860977338164064},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.180725597089732,3.226020550760265,3.1304510833322565,3.0017150880217516,2.7512081213421826,2.4612505545216217,2.2061549628418398,1.9597151649642446,1.6703586605134282,1.2675515721774024,1.2613183918846367,1.2684079790623226,1.2856527500929469,1.326116568478885,1.3344910769856693,1.3426220654643135,1.350565392487557,1.3583321422333647,1.3659336023429076,1.373380080425071],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.946494945197054,0.9461919100411467,0.9436530257637104,0.94040639958285,0.9074594127455059,0.8676072137173433,0.8462903253971283,0.8369523670469586,0.818688974498951,0.7444189152467581,0.7323408133830519,0.7329373914539024,0.7393326891244343,0.7590563010151006,0.7604043901118658,0.7616856209509821,0.7629272738700908,0.7641314050838195,0.7653005319659069,0.7664369244449942],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.8393131934922915,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.7323408133830519,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.37533306340389916}}},{"q":0.45,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"owners_only","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":3.54702933691442e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.45,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"per_capita","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":3.8198777474462986e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.088047162869531,4.208832313825646,4.148739186639279,4.0509290113114105,3.9124209323463033,3.73340567491786,3.514072734486768,3.2547249783150343,2.955769294557877,2.6177023752654316,2.6423316261087546,2.6536970355955853,2.6649149892326385,2.6756325317483216,2.6858992475950267,2.695748958453345,2.7052124054922118,2.714317328367679,2.7230888351692553,2.731549711400541],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9982580685627074,0.9982736658011704,0.9982156713754592,0.9981405180070276,0.9980431433783115,0.9979178898131184,0.9977561918401885,0.9975448220009387,0.9972624438495867,0.9968725017127583,0.996901562892227,0.9969147921193813,0.9969277393950087,0.9969400080180921,0.9969516690294372,0.9969627731737192,0.9969733659248531,0.9969834878596396,0.9969931753137427,0.9970024609265602],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9974943399998176,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9968725017127583,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.639215354690339},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3533974680029517,3.402199636383977,3.309959187999876,3.1843872603392125,3.024098829147551,2.829036249654995,2.5989509409859064,2.3334788861032036,2.032170991297579,1.6945270639118206,1.7140981186475894,1.7223690766797435,1.730724160272619,1.738847017183265,1.74676295854114,1.7544859082471094,1.7620287862396569,1.7694033645729699,1.7766204006700606,1.7836897460710093],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.997877262850176,0.9978652403602352,0.9977645137280566,0.997635708439826,0.9974697756576199,0.9972541209018019,0.9969685151694471,0.9965788457904851,0.9960232039989215,0.9951768641701978,0.9952316706910811,0.9952544599378389,0.9952772608734948,0.9952992189881429,0.9953204221939788,0.9953409249316911,0.9953607769338957,0.9953800231128556,0.9953987041552772,0.9954168570142755],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9964949652716112,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9951768641701978,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5042438435933072}}},{"q":0.45,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"displacement_cohorts","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":5.434230843093246e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.059513066950264,4.179718649268886,4.119075400350395,4.020742361574425,3.8817367004707966,3.7022473519060792,3.4824621861772838,3.22268259191389,2.9233141090190142,2.584852197610477,2.6094814484538,2.620846857940631,2.632064811577685,2.642782354093367,2.653049069940072,2.6628987807983906,2.6723622278372576,2.681467150712725,2.6902386575143007,2.698699533745587],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9912903428135367,0.9913683290058527,0.9910783568772964,0.9907025900351382,0.9902157168915571,0.989589449065592,0.9887809592009421,0.9877241100046944,0.9863122192479339,0.9843625085637921,0.9845078144611344,0.9845739605969074,0.9846386969750448,0.9847000400904609,0.9847583451471862,0.9848138658685958,0.9848668296242663,0.9849174392981987,0.9849658765687136,0.9850123046328015],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9874716999990887,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9843625085637921,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6311936872312096},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.324863372083685,3.3730859718272166,3.2802954017109913,3.154200610602227,2.9934145972720447,2.7978779266432143,2.567340392676422,2.30143649970206,1.9997158057587163,1.661676886256866,1.681247940992635,1.689518899024789,1.6978739826176643,1.7059968395283103,1.7139127808861856,1.7216357305921548,1.7291786085847023,1.7365531869180155,1.743770223015106,1.7508395684160551],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.98938631425088,0.9893262018011763,0.9888225686402843,0.9881785421991299,0.9873488782881,0.9862706045090103,0.9848425758472359,0.9828942289524254,0.9801160199946087,0.9758843208509883,0.9761583534554061,0.9762722996891949,0.976386304367473,0.9764960949407142,0.9766021109698938,0.9767046246584559,0.976803884669478,0.9769001155642784,0.9769935207763856,0.9770842850713781],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9824748263580568,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9758843208509883,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.49446854982773103}}},{"q":0.45,"tax_timing":"december","policy":"owners_only","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":3.637978807091713e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.45,"tax_timing":"december","policy":"per_capita","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":4.6838977141305804e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.054724472998414,4.174832792068184,4.114097221682536,4.0156764359265225,3.876587270553972,3.6970183599819566,3.4771573017724045,3.217305236410584,2.9178674775358484,2.5793392785230536,2.6039685293663766,2.6153339388532078,2.626551892490261,2.637269435005944,2.647536150852649,2.657385861710967,2.666849308749834,2.6759542316253015,2.6847257384268777,2.6931866146581633],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9901210185961151,0.9902094749069844,0.9898805722642827,0.9894543564481602,0.9889021176368593,0.9881917695629794,0.9872747350383003,0.9860759974378507,0.9844745517974833,0.9822630806477891,0.9824278947417295,0.982502921396769,0.9825763490256735,0.9826459278257893,0.9827120606894382,0.982775035403895,0.9828351098644791,0.9828925141935969,0.982947454460984,0.9830001157738142],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9857896998605581,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9822630806477891,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6298474904430857},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3200747781318354,3.3682001146265144,3.275317223043134,3.149134684954325,2.9882651673552205,2.7926489347190917,2.562035508271543,2.2960591441987535,1.994269174275551,1.6561639671694428,1.6757239841239466,1.6840059799373657,1.692361063530241,1.7004839204408873,1.708399861798762,1.7161228115047318,1.723665689497279,1.731040267830592,1.7382573039276827,1.7453266493286315],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9879613626693371,0.9878931797592579,0.9873219307968348,0.9865914399061413,0.9856503885911388,0.984427350027867,0.982807599871017,0.9805976756076298,0.9774464752741618,0.9726466448960345,0.9729510593317839,0.9730867122426231,0.9732160227392997,0.9733405533618206,0.9734608026848828,0.9735770794568923,0.9736896657254493,0.9737988162005896,0.9739047616280249,0.9740077115792307],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9801217226617865,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9726466448960345,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.4928280593515011}}},{"q":0.45,"tax_timing":"december","policy":"displacement_cohorts","receipt_schedule_supported":false,"max_collection_gap":0.14018012336619207,"first_collection_gap_month":"0008-12","max_cash_error":4.433786671143025e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":26},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.892899617594681,4.009721040481572,3.945865575566679,3.8444794846499866,3.702568391509141,3.5203107772265616,3.297885022605466,3.0355838823916375,2.733805023908871,2.393036713898588,2.4176659647419108,2.4290313742287424,2.4402493278657955,2.450966870381478,2.4612335862281833,2.4710832970865018,2.480546744125369,2.489651667000836,2.498423173802412,2.5068840500336975],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9506050929805756,0.951047374534922,0.9494028613214135,0.9472717822408016,0.9445105881842968,0.9409588478148974,0.9363736751915013,0.9303799871892534,0.9223727589874166,0.9113154032389462,0.9121394737086477,0.9125146069838456,0.912881745128368,0.9132296391289464,0.913560303447191,0.9138751770194751,0.9141755493223964,0.9144625709679848,0.9147372723049196,0.9150005788690709],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9289484993027907,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9113154032389462,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5843543659949436},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.158249922728102,3.2030883630399023,3.1070855769272767,2.9779377336777886,2.8140926919346896,2.484323599540434,2.2062241495881953,1.9366424631578625,1.6576661700520356,1.2829538659829371,1.2400839124181007,1.257070504718421,1.3189484566498875,1.3261381336715825,1.3345126421783673,1.342643630657011,1.3505869576802545,1.3583537074260625,1.3659551675356054,1.3734016456177693],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9398068133466856,0.93946589879629,0.9366096539841743,0.9329571995307064,0.9282012806754357,0.8757406157653267,0.8463168657241102,0.8270985103558143,0.812468033903785,0.7534645107859851,0.7200117487596044,0.7263861405878854,0.7584798532893001,0.7590686447228777,0.7604166781424745,0.7616978551437704,0.7629394559338152,0.7641435366093019,0.7653126144371304,0.7664489592489079],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.8387404973232653,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.7200117487596044,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.36901427642731865}}},{"q":0.5,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"owners_only","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":3.637978807091713e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.5,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"per_capita","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":4.18367562815547e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.087254549093995,4.208023600921292,4.1479151925757,4.050090493263161,3.9115685925719834,3.73254016594531,3.5131946637003932,3.2538349120261136,2.9548677616262418,2.616789870330572,2.641419121173895,2.6527845306607256,2.664002484297779,2.674720026813462,2.6849867426601666,2.694836453518485,2.704299900557352,2.7134048234328194,2.7221763302343955,2.7306372064656816],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9980645206252302,0.9980818508901895,0.9980174126393992,0.9979339088966973,0.9978257148647904,0.997686544236798,0.9975068798224316,0.9972720244454876,0.9969582709439853,0.9965250019030649,0.9965572921024745,0.9965719912437571,0.9965863771055654,0.9966000089089913,0.9966129655882634,0.9966253035263546,0.9966370732498367,0.9966483198440441,0.9966590836819363,0.9966694010295115],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9972159333331307,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9965250019030649,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6389925305942521},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3526048542274163,3.4013909234796227,3.3091351939362967,3.183548742290963,3.023246489373232,2.8281707406824452,2.598072870199532,2.332588819814283,2.0312694583659443,1.6936145589769607,1.7131856137127297,1.7214565717448835,1.729811655337759,1.7379345122484051,1.7458504536062798,1.7535734033122496,1.761116281304797,1.76849085963811,1.7757078957352006,1.7827772411361493],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9976414031668621,0.9976280448447058,0.9975161263645076,0.9973730093775844,0.9971886396195778,0.9969490232242243,0.996631683521608,0.9961987175449833,0.9955813377765798,0.9946409601891085,0.9947018563234236,0.9947271777087098,0.9947525120816606,0.9947769099868253,0.9948004691044207,0.9948232499241013,0.9948453077043284,0.9948666923476173,0.994887449061419,0.9949076189047505],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.996105516968457,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9946409601891085,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5039723076553745}}},{"q":0.5,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"displacement_cohorts","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":4.75210981676355e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.055549998072587,4.1756750847471125,4.114955430032493,4.016549771333176,3.8774750015991977,3.6979198070433315,3.4780718322454103,3.2182322604692866,2.918806444360839,2.580289672936178,2.6049189237795005,2.616284333266332,2.6275022869033853,2.638219829419068,2.648486545265773,2.658336256124091,2.6677997031629586,2.6769046260384255,2.6856761328400016,2.6941370090712873],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9903226031261517,0.9904092544509472,0.9900870631969958,0.9896695444834868,0.9891285743239521,0.9884327211839911,0.9875343991121577,0.9863601222274382,0.9847913547199265,0.9826250095153247,0.9827864605123715,0.9828599562187861,0.9829318855278275,0.9830000445449566,0.983064827941318,0.983126517631773,0.9831853662491848,0.9832415992202207,0.9832954184096819,0.9833470051475571],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.986079666665654,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9826250095153247,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.630079566750775},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3209003032060083,3.369042407305444,3.2761754313930904,3.1500080203609793,2.9891528984004463,2.793550381780467,2.562950038744549,2.2969861682574564,1.9952081411005411,1.657114361582567,1.6766854163183358,1.6849563743504898,1.693311457943365,1.7014343148540114,1.709350256211886,1.7170732059178557,1.7246160839104032,1.7319906622437162,1.739207698340807,1.7462770437417556],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9882070158343109,0.988140224223529,0.9875806318225381,0.9868650468879222,0.9859431980978888,0.9847451161211225,0.9831584176080399,0.980993587724917,0.9779066888828987,0.9732048009455426,0.9735092816171179,0.97363588854355,0.9737625604083032,0.9738845499341271,0.9740023455221041,0.9741162496205067,0.9742265385216422,0.9743334617380871,0.9744372453070952,0.9745380945237534],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9805275848422854,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9732048009455426,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.49311087013806776}}},{"q":0.5,"tax_timing":"december","policy":"owners_only","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":4.320099833421409e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.5,"tax_timing":"december","policy":"per_capita","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":3.7971403799019754e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.050229338126088,4.170246354524111,4.10942412040154,4.01092096505773,3.8717534128027267,3.6921098160165284,3.4721775162399897,3.2122574210211683,2.9127546316017656,2.574164207283485,2.598793458126808,2.6101588676136394,2.621376821250693,2.6320943637663756,2.6423610796130803,2.6522107904713987,2.6616742375102658,2.6707791603857336,2.679550667187309,2.688011543418595],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9890233539956834,0.9891216387855383,0.9887561914047586,0.9882826182757337,0.9876690195965103,0.9868797439588659,0.9858608167092227,0.9845288860420561,0.9827495019972037,0.9802923118308768,0.9804754386019218,0.9805588015519655,0.980640387806304,0.9807176975842103,0.9807911785438201,0.9808611504487722,0.9809278998494213,0.9809916824373301,0.9810527271788709,0.9811112397486824],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9842107776228423,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9802923118308768,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6285837925417485},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3155796432595084,3.3636136770824416,3.270644121762137,3.1443792140855322,2.9834313096039753,2.787740390753664,2.557055722739128,2.2910113288093386,1.9891563283414682,1.6509888959298742,1.6705599506656434,1.678830908697797,1.687185992290673,1.6953088492013189,1.7032247905591937,1.7109477402651632,1.7184906182577104,1.7258651965910237,1.7330822326881141,1.7401515780890633],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9866237362992631,0.9865479775102866,0.9859132564409273,0.9851015998957126,0.9840559873234876,0.9826970555865188,0.980897333190019,0.9784418617862554,0.974940528082402,0.9696073832178159,0.9699527422632916,0.9700963469362478,0.9702400252658888,0.9703783926242452,0.9705120029832033,0.9706411993965469,0.9707662952504992,0.9708875735562108,0.9710052906978053,0.9711196795324788],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9779132951948135,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9696073832178159,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.4912881029422566}}},{"q":0.5,"tax_timing":"december","policy":"displacement_cohorts","receipt_schedule_supported":false,"max_collection_gap":0.12184563456345887,"first_collection_gap_month":"0009-12","max_cash_error":5.161382432561368e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":26},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.8704239432330514,3.986788852761209,3.9225000691616994,3.820702130306023,3.6783991027529153,3.495768057399424,3.2729860949433913,3.010344805444562,2.7082407942384576,2.3671613577007458,2.3917906085440683,2.4031560180308995,2.4143739716679526,2.4250915141836353,2.4353582300303405,2.445207940888659,2.454671387927526,2.4637763108029933,2.472547817604569,2.481008693835855],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9451167699784173,0.9456081939276912,0.9437809570237928,0.9414130913786685,0.9383450979825522,0.9343987197943305,0.9293040835461126,0.9226444302102816,0.9137475099860184,0.9014615591543846,0.9023771930096085,0.9027940077598283,0.9032019390315198,0.9035884879210514,0.9039558927191009,0.904305752243861,0.904639499247107,0.9049584121866496,0.905263635894355,0.9055561987434121],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9210538881142117,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9014615591543846,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5780358764882573},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.135774248366472,3.1801561753195395,3.083720070522296,2.9541603793338256,2.790076999554163,2.559225798581501,2.206293336334551,1.9141164649386169,1.6345788569873747,1.308379611874841,1.2342857780352043,1.2630125383486919,1.318970021842585,1.3261596988642803,1.3345342073710649,1.3426651958497087,1.3506085228729523,1.3583752726187606,1.3659767327283032,1.373423210810467],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9331186814963172,0.9327398875514334,0.9295662822046379,0.9255079994785628,0.9202799366174378,0.9021441398161127,0.846343406051092,0.817478139055561,0.801152303274392,0.7683967680539692,0.7166452629639521,0.7298196877594522,0.7584922546565491,0.759080988430655,0.7604289661730831,0.7617100893365588,0.7629516379975397,0.7641556681347844,0.7653246969083539,0.766460994052821],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.8373872259967036,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.7166452629639521,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.3672889138591028}}},{"q":0.55,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"owners_only","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":3.4788172342814505e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.55,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"per_capita","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":4.5702108764089644e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.08646193531846,4.207214888016938,4.147091198512119,4.049251975214911,3.910716252797664,3.7316746569727615,3.512316592914019,3.2529448457371934,2.9539662286946067,2.6158773653957117,2.640506616239035,2.651872025725866,2.6630899793629195,2.6738075218786017,2.684074237725307,2.6939239485836253,2.7033873956224923,2.7124923184979597,2.721263825299536,2.7297247015308215],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9978709726877534,0.9978900359792084,0.9978191539033392,0.9977272997863671,0.9976082863512695,0.997455198660478,0.9972575678046748,0.9969992268900364,0.9966540980383838,0.9961775020933713,0.9962130213127219,0.9962291903681328,0.996245014816122,0.9962600097998903,0.9962742621470898,0.99628783387899,0.9963007805748205,0.9963131518284486,0.99632499205013,0.9963363411324626],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9969375266664439,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9961775020933713,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6387697064981651},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3518122404518813,3.4005822105752683,3.3083111998727164,3.1827102242427134,3.022394149598912,2.8273052317098966,2.5971947994131575,2.3316987535253624,2.0303679254343097,1.6927020540421007,1.71227310877787,1.7205440668100236,1.7288991504028994,1.7370220073135454,1.7449379486714203,1.7526608983773897,1.760203776369937,1.7675783547032502,1.7747953908003407,1.7818647362012898],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9974055434835484,0.9973908493291763,0.9972677390009582,0.9971103103153428,0.9969075035815356,0.996643925546647,0.9962948518737688,0.9958185892994817,0.9951394715542379,0.9941050562080194,0.9941720419557659,0.9941998954795808,0.9942277632898269,0.994254600985508,0.9942805160148629,0.9943055749165114,0.9943298384747613,0.9943533615823791,0.9943761939675609,0.9943983807952258],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9957160686653026,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9941050562080194,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5037007717174418}}},{"q":0.55,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"displacement_cohorts","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":6.252776074688882e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.051586929194912,4.171631520225342,4.110835459714593,4.012357181091929,3.8732133027276,3.6935922621805846,3.473681478313538,3.213781929024684,2.9142987797026634,2.575727148261879,2.6003563991052014,2.6117218085920326,2.6229397622290858,2.633657304744769,2.6439240205914736,2.653773731449792,2.663237178488659,2.6723421013641264,2.681113608165702,2.689574484396988],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9893548634387669,0.9894501798960422,0.9890957695166955,0.9886364989318355,0.9880414317563475,0.9872759933023902,0.9862878390233737,0.9849961344501822,0.9832704901919191,0.9808875104668572,0.9810651065636087,0.9811459518406647,0.9812250740806101,0.9813000489994523,0.9813713107354497,0.9814391693949502,0.9815039028741033,0.9815657591422429,0.98162496025065,0.9816817056623129],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9846876333322195,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9808875104668572,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6289654462703405},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.316937234328332,3.3649988427836717,3.2720554610751904,3.145815430119731,2.984891199528848,2.7892228369177197,2.5585596848126766,2.292535836812853,1.990700476442366,1.6525518369082675,1.6721228916440367,1.6803938496761905,1.688748933269066,1.696871790179712,1.7047877315375868,1.7125106812435567,1.7200535592361037,1.727428137569417,1.7346451736665074,1.7417145190674563],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.987027717417742,0.9869542466458819,0.9863386950047921,0.9855515515767145,0.9845375179076775,0.9832196277332348,0.981474259368844,0.9790929464974085,0.9756973577711886,0.9705252810400967,0.9708602097788298,0.9709994773979049,0.9711388164491337,0.9712730049275397,0.9714025800743145,0.9715278745825574,0.9716491923738063,0.9717668079118957,0.9718809698378045,0.9719919039761287],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9785803433265139,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9705252810400967,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.4917531904484043}}},{"q":0.55,"tax_timing":"december","policy":"owners_only","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":3.319655661471188e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.55,"tax_timing":"december","policy":"per_capita","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":4.411049303598702e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.045734203253763,4.165659916980038,4.1047510191205445,4.006165494188938,3.866919555051482,3.687201272051102,3.467197730707575,3.207209605631754,2.907641785667683,2.5689891360439168,2.59361838688724,2.604983796374071,2.6162017500111245,2.6269192925268072,2.637186008373512,2.64703571923183,2.6564991662706974,2.6656040891461643,2.674375595947741,2.6828364721790265],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9879256893952519,0.988033802664092,0.9876318105452345,0.9871108801033072,0.9864359215561616,0.9855677183547528,0.9844468983801449,0.9829817746462619,0.981024452196924,0.9783215430139646,0.9785229824621139,0.9786146817071621,0.9787044265869345,0.9787894673426314,0.9788702963982021,0.9789472654936493,0.9790206898343635,0.9790908506810628,0.9791579998967582,0.9792223637235508],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9826318553851267,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9783215430139646,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6273200946404113},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.311084508387183,3.3590272395383693,3.265971020481142,3.13962374321674,2.9785974518527296,2.7828318467882367,2.552075937206713,2.2859635134199228,1.9840434824073858,1.6458138246903058,1.6653848794260748,1.6736558374582287,1.682010921051104,1.6901337779617505,1.698049719319625,1.7057726690255945,1.713315547018142,1.7206901253514553,1.7279071614485457,1.7349765068494944],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9852861099291897,0.9852027752613153,0.9845045820850203,0.9836117598852839,0.9824615860558363,0.9809667611451708,0.9789870665090208,0.9762860479648806,0.9724345808906423,0.9665681215395976,0.9669480164896207,0.9671059816298727,0.9672640277924774,0.9674162318866697,0.9675632032815233,0.9677053193362016,0.9678429247755491,0.9679763309118319,0.9681058197675858,0.9682316474857264],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9757046247142949,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9665681215395976,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.4897481465330122}}},{"q":0.55,"tax_timing":"december","policy":"displacement_cohorts","receipt_schedule_supported":false,"max_collection_gap":0.09303454209008755,"first_collection_gap_month":"0009-12","max_cash_error":5.775291356258094e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":24},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.8479482688714226,3.9638566650408467,3.8991345627567195,3.79692477596206,3.6542298139966887,3.471225337572286,3.2480871672813163,2.9851057284974862,2.682676564568044,2.3412860015029033,2.3659152523462263,2.377280661833057,2.3884986154701107,2.3992161579857934,2.4094828738324985,2.4193325846908165,2.4287960317296835,2.4379009546051513,2.446672461406727,2.4551333376380127],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9396284469762592,0.9401690133204604,0.9381590527261723,0.9355544005165354,0.9321796077808073,0.9278385917737637,0.9222344919007237,0.9149088732313099,0.9051222609846202,0.8916077150698232,0.8926149123105696,0.8930734085358112,0.893522132934672,0.8939473367131567,0.8943514819910112,0.894736327468247,0.8951034491718177,0.8954542534053148,0.8957899994837907,0.8961118186177534],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.913159276925633,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.8916077150698232,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5717173869815708},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.113298574004843,3.1572239875991768,3.0603545641173167,2.930383024989862,2.765907710797937,2.566540976585036,2.224285512535744,1.9141865968591028,1.6112089116707478,1.2984427267837473,1.246657205773652,1.2630362605399135,1.3189915870352829,1.3261812640569783,1.334555772563763,1.3426867610424071,1.3506300880656505,1.358396837811459,1.3659982979210012,1.3734447760031652],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9264305496459492,0.9260138763065767,0.9225229104251019,0.9180587994264191,0.9123079302791817,0.9047227887853669,0.8532452805378671,0.8175080908964741,0.7896980467619105,0.7625609461570055,0.7238283037496708,0.7298333954002433,0.7585046560237982,0.7590933321384323,0.7604412542036919,0.7617223235293477,0.7629638200612645,0.7641677996602673,0.7653367793795777,0.7664730288567346],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.8349195772105227,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.7238283037496708,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.37097030461787345}}},{"q":0.6,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"owners_only","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":3.319655661471188e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.6,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"per_capita","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":4.388311936054379e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.085669321542925,4.206406175112583,4.146267204448539,4.048413457166662,3.909863913023344,3.730809148000212,3.5114385221276447,3.2520547794482724,2.953064695762972,2.6149648604608524,2.639594111304175,2.650959520791006,2.6621774744280593,2.6728950169437424,2.683161732790447,2.6930114436487655,2.7024748906876326,2.7115798135631,2.7203513203646756,2.7288121965959617],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9976774247502764,0.9976982210682275,0.997620895167279,0.9975206906760369,0.9973908578377485,0.9972238530841578,0.9970082557869181,0.9967264293345851,0.9963499251327824,0.995830002283678,0.9958687505229692,0.9958863894925085,0.9959036525266785,0.9959200106907896,0.9959355587059162,0.9959503642316255,0.9959644878998043,0.9959779838128531,0.9959909004183235,0.9960032812354138],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9966591199997569,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.995830002283678,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6385468824020784},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3510196266763463,3.399773497670914,3.307487205809137,3.181871706194464,3.0215418098245928,2.826439722737347,2.5963167286267828,2.330808687236442,2.029466392502674,1.691789549107241,1.71136060384301,1.7196315618751639,1.7279866454680395,1.7361095023786857,1.7440254437365605,1.7517483934425297,1.7592912714350772,1.7666658497683907,1.773882885865481,1.78095223126643],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9971696838002346,0.997153653813647,0.9970193516374093,0.9968476112531013,0.9966263675434934,0.9963388278690695,0.9959580202259295,0.9954384610539803,0.9946976053318957,0.9935691522269303,0.9936422275881083,0.9936726132504519,0.9937030144979929,0.9937322919841906,0.9937605629253051,0.9937878999089215,0.9938143692451942,0.993840030817141,0.9938649388737029,0.9938891426857009],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9953266203621486,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9935691522269303,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5034292357795092}}},{"q":0.6,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"displacement_cohorts","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":4.411049303598702e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.047623860317235,4.167587955703569,4.1067154893966915,4.008164590850681,3.8689516038560017,3.6892647173178377,3.4692911243816646,3.2093315975800802,2.909791115044488,2.5711646235875794,2.5957938744309024,2.607159283917733,2.6183772375547867,2.6290947800704694,2.639361495917174,2.6492112067754925,2.65867465381436,2.6677795766898273,2.676551083491403,2.685011959722689],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9883871237513819,0.9884911053411369,0.9881044758363948,0.9876034533801843,0.9869542891887426,0.9861192654207895,0.9850412789345893,0.983632146672926,0.9817496256639118,0.9791500114183896,0.979343752614846,0.9794319474625431,0.9795182626333929,0.979600053453948,0.9796777935295814,0.9797518211581275,0.9798224394990218,0.979889919064265,0.9799545020916183,0.9800164061770686],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9832955999987849,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9791500114183896,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6278513257899058},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3129741654506564,3.3609552782619003,3.2679354907572895,3.1416228398784836,2.98062950065725,2.7848952920549723,2.5541693308808036,2.2880855053682496,1.98619281178419,1.6479893122339682,1.6675603669697372,1.675831325001891,1.6841864085947669,1.6923092655054126,1.7002252068632875,1.7079481565692571,1.7154910345618044,1.7228656128951174,1.730082648992208,1.737151994393157],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9858484190011731,0.9857682690682352,0.9850967581870459,0.9842380562655068,0.9831318377174665,0.981694139345347,0.9797901011296479,0.9771923052699003,0.9734880266594782,0.9678457611346509,0.9682111379405415,0.9683630662522598,0.9685150724899642,0.9686614599209523,0.9688028146265248,0.968939499544608,0.9690718462259704,0.9692001540857043,0.969324694368514,0.9694457134285039],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9766331018107424,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9678457611346509,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.49039551075874094}}},{"q":0.6,"tax_timing":"december","policy":"owners_only","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":3.456079866737127e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.6,"tax_timing":"december","policy":"per_capita","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":3.1377567211166024e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.0412390683814365,4.161073479435966,4.100077917839549,4.001410023320145,3.8620856973002367,3.682292728085674,3.4622179451751594,3.2021617902423385,2.9025289397336005,2.5638140648043484,2.588443315647671,2.599808725134502,2.6110266787715553,2.6217442212872384,2.6320109371339435,2.641860647992262,2.6513240950311285,2.660429017906596,2.669200524708172,2.6776614009394577],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9868280247948202,0.9869459665426458,0.9865074296857105,0.9859391419308804,0.9852028235158126,0.9842556927506393,0.983032980051067,0.9814346632504676,0.9792994023966445,0.9763507741970523,0.976570526322306,0.9766705618623586,0.9767684653675646,0.9768612371010523,0.9769494142525842,0.9770333805385267,0.9771134798193055,0.9771900189247958,0.9772632726146452,0.9773334876984189],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9810529331474108,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9763507741970523,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.626056396739074},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.306589373514857,3.354440801994297,3.2612979192001452,3.134868272347947,2.9737635941014844,2.777923302822809,2.5470961516742983,2.280915698030508,1.9789306364733028,1.6406387534507374,1.6602098081865062,1.6684807662186603,1.6768358498115354,1.6849587067221818,1.6928746480800565,1.7005975977860261,1.7081404757785736,1.7155150541118867,1.7227320902089773,1.729801435609926],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.983948483559116,0.9838575730123441,0.9830959077291129,0.982121919874855,0.980867184788185,0.9792364667038226,0.9770767998280228,0.9741302341435063,0.9699286336988824,0.9635288598613793,0.9639432907159498,0.9641156163234975,0.9642880303190662,0.9644540711490941,0.9646144035798437,0.9647694392758563,0.9649195543005991,0.965065088267453,0.9652063488373664,0.9653436154389744],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9734959542337763,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9635288598613793,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.48820819012376776}}},{"q":0.6,"tax_timing":"december","policy":"displacement_cohorts","receipt_schedule_supported":false,"max_collection_gap":0.06783320533328574,"first_collection_gap_month":"0009-12","max_cash_error":4.729372449219227e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":15},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.8254725945097925,3.9409244773204843,3.8757690563517397,3.773147421618097,3.630060525240463,3.446682617745148,3.2231882396192413,2.95986665155041,2.6571123348976307,2.3154106453050605,2.340039896148384,2.3514053056352147,2.362623259272268,2.3733408017879505,2.3836075176346556,2.393457228492974,2.402920675531841,2.4120255984073085,2.4207971052088846,2.4292579814401702],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9341401239741008,0.9347298327132296,0.9325371484285516,0.9296957096544023,0.9260141175790627,0.9212784637531968,0.9151649002553349,0.9071733162523379,0.8964970119832221,0.8817538709852615,0.8828526316115304,0.883352809311794,0.8838423268378238,0.8843061855052617,0.8847470712629212,0.8851669026926332,0.8855673990965285,0.8859500946239797,0.8863163630732261,0.8866674384920946],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9052646657370542,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.8817538709852615,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5653988974748844},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.0908228996432134,3.1342917998788145,3.036989057712336,2.9066056706458987,2.7417384220417103,2.542271152439692,2.3077083548485375,1.9206380419885818,1.5878155064404051,1.2750540376911914,1.2726126449593087,1.2630599827311342,1.3087260819041897,1.316231477772255,1.3255106791212057,1.3439941660197592,1.3519181300633971,1.3596668141055184,1.3672513663684343,1.3746820022095128],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9197424177955809,0.9192878650617202,0.9154795386455656,0.9106095993742753,0.9043359239409254,0.8961675141240902,0.8852466338224544,0.820263364912068,0.778232291896916,0.7488250296503378,0.7388984300296313,0.7298471030410338,0.7526013329738976,0.7533981706777503,0.7552872828648739,0.7624640300732993,0.7636914281988912,0.7648822263750817,0.7660388442147682,0.7671634829138099],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.832831901353904,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.7298471030410338,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.3758513121124076}}},{"q":0.65,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"owners_only","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":4.501998773775995e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.65,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"per_capita","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":4.229150363244116e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.08487670776739,4.205597462208228,4.145443210384959,4.047574939118412,3.9090115732490247,3.7299436390276623,3.51056045134127,3.2511647131593513,2.952163162831337,2.6140523555259927,2.6386816063693153,2.6500470158561464,2.6612649694931996,2.6719825120088827,2.6822492278555874,2.692098938713906,2.701562385752773,2.7106673086282402,2.719438815429816,2.727899691661102],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9974838768127995,0.9975064061572462,0.9974226364312191,0.9973140815657067,0.9971734293242276,0.9969925075078376,0.9967589437691612,0.9964536317791337,0.996045752227181,0.9954825024739845,0.9955244797332167,0.9955435886168843,0.9955622902372351,0.9955800115816889,0.9955968552647426,0.995612894584261,0.995628195224788,0.9956428157972574,0.9956568087865172,0.9956702213383649],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.99638071333307,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9954825024739845,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6383240583059914},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.350227012900811,3.3989647847665596,3.306663211745556,3.1810331881462144,3.020689470050273,2.8255742137647974,2.5954386578404085,2.3299186209475216,2.0285648595710395,1.6908770441723813,1.71044809890815,1.7187190569403041,1.7270741405331793,1.7351969974438257,1.7431129388017004,1.75083588850767,1.7583787665002175,1.7657533448335307,1.7729703809306212,1.7800397263315701],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9969338241169209,0.9969164582981176,0.9967709642738598,0.9965849121908598,0.9963452315054511,0.9960337301914919,0.9956211885780905,0.9950583328084787,0.9942557391095538,0.9930332482458412,0.9931124132204505,0.9931453310213229,0.9931782657061587,0.9932099829828731,0.993240609835747,0.9932702249013317,0.993298900015627,0.9933267000519027,0.9933536837798448,0.9933799045761759],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9949371720589941,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9930332482458412,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5031576998415765}}},{"q":0.65,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"displacement_cohorts","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":5.5706550483591855e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.043660791439559,4.163544391181796,4.1025955190787915,4.0039720006094335,3.8646899049844032,3.68493717245509,3.464900770449792,3.2048812661354766,2.905283450386312,2.56660209891328,2.591231349756603,2.602596759243434,2.613814712880487,2.6245322553961703,2.634798971242875,2.6446486821011934,2.6541121291400604,2.663217052015528,2.6719885588171035,2.6804494350483896],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9874193840639972,0.9875320307862315,0.9871131821560946,0.9865704078285331,0.9858671466211377,0.9849625375391885,0.9837947188458052,0.9822681588956698,0.9802287611359042,0.977412512369922,0.9776223986660829,0.9777179430844218,0.9778114511861756,0.9779000579084437,0.9779842763237133,0.9780644729213048,0.9781409761239401,0.978214078986287,0.9782840439325864,0.9783511066918242],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9819035666653504,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.977412512369922,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.626737205309471},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3090110965729806,3.356911713740127,3.2638155204393886,3.1374302496372355,2.9763678017856514,2.7805677471922245,2.5497789769489305,2.283635173923646,1.9816851471260148,1.6434267875596689,1.6629978422954381,1.6712688003275917,1.6796238839204674,1.6877467408311135,1.695662682188988,1.7033856318949578,1.7109285098875051,1.7183030882208183,1.7255201243179088,1.7325894697188575],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9846691205846043,0.9845822914905878,0.9838548213692997,0.9829245609542989,0.9817261575272553,0.9801686509574591,0.9781059428904518,0.9752916640423919,0.9712786955477682,0.9651662412292051,0.9655620661022534,0.9657266551066148,0.9658913285307943,0.9660499149143652,0.9662030491787351,0.9663511245066586,0.9664945000781346,0.9666335002595131,0.9667684188992234,0.9668995228808792],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.974685860294971,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9651662412292051,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.48903783106907756}}},{"q":0.65,"tax_timing":"december","policy":"owners_only","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":4.3655745685100555e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.65,"tax_timing":"december","policy":"per_capita","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":4.092726157978177e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.03674393350911,4.156487041891893,4.095404816558552,3.9966545524513517,3.857251839548991,3.677384184120246,3.4572381596427446,3.197113974852923,2.8974160937995177,2.55863899356478,2.583268244408103,2.5946336538949337,2.6058516075319873,2.61656915004767,2.6268358658943747,2.636685576752693,2.6461490237915606,2.655253946667028,2.6640254534686036,2.6724863296998898],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9857303601943885,0.9858581304211996,0.985383048826186,0.9847674037584536,0.9839697254754636,0.9829436671465258,0.9816190617219893,0.9798875518546731,0.9775743525963648,0.97438000538014,0.9746180701824984,0.9747264420175552,0.9748325041481952,0.9749330068594734,0.975028532106966,0.9751194955834038,0.9752062698042478,0.9752891871685291,0.9753685453325323,0.9754446116732873],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.979474010909695,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.97438000538014,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6247926988377367},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.302094238642531,3.3498543644502234,3.2566248179191497,3.1301128014791546,2.968929736350239,2.7730147588573812,2.542116366141883,2.2758678826410925,1.9738177905392202,1.6354636822111688,1.6550347369469378,1.6633056949790916,1.6716607785719675,1.6797836354826132,1.687699576840488,1.6954225265464578,1.702965404539005,1.710339982872318,1.7175570189694087,1.7246263643703577],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9826108571890423,0.9825123707633724,0.9816872333732058,0.9806320798644264,0.9792727835205338,0.9775061722624745,0.9751665331470246,0.9719744203221317,0.9674226865071226,0.9604895981831608,0.960938564942279,0.9611252510171223,0.9613120328456554,0.9614919104115186,0.9616656038781641,0.9618335592155111,0.9619961838256489,0.9621538456230739,0.9623068779071469,0.9624555833922223],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9712872837532577,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9604895981831608,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.4866682337145233}}},{"q":0.65,"tax_timing":"december","policy":"displacement_cohorts","receipt_schedule_supported":false,"max_collection_gap":0.04176798145410887,"first_collection_gap_month":"0010-12","max_cash_error":4.206412995699793e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":14},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.8029969201481624,3.9179922896001202,3.8524035499467586,3.7493700672741337,3.6058912364842355,3.4221398979180098,3.198289311957166,2.934627574603334,2.6315481052272176,2.2895352891072185,2.314164539950541,2.3255299494373727,2.3367479030744254,2.347465445590108,2.3577321614368136,2.3675818722951316,2.377045319333999,2.386150242209466,2.3949217490110417,2.4033826252423274],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9286518009719424,0.9292906521059985,0.9269152441309306,0.9238370187922691,0.9198486273773177,0.9147183357326298,0.9080953086099459,0.8994377592733661,0.887871762981824,0.8719000269007001,0.8730903509124911,0.873632210087777,0.8741625207409759,0.874665034297367,0.8751426605348315,0.8755974779170194,0.8760313490212394,0.8764459358426446,0.8768427266626615,0.8772230583664357],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.8973700545484753,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.8719000269007001,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.559080407968198},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.0683472252815838,3.1113596121584512,3.013623551307356,2.8828283163019353,2.717569133285484,2.5177704726551444,2.2830323214258152,1.986341533927695,1.5844990472836105,1.2514043926499276,1.2692352925898136,1.2721815638426461,1.3089590686680581,1.3275931370319753,1.3359042577221307,1.344015731212456,1.351939695256094,1.3596883792982153,1.3672729315611316,1.3747035674022103],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9130542859452127,0.9125618538168635,0.9084361668660296,0.9031603993221315,0.8963639176026693,0.887530861312372,0.8757808035854316,0.8483239188562401,0.7766068035450854,0.7349358566225721,0.736937487418098,0.7351179212447707,0.7527353152880558,0.7599014745773235,0.761209632540653,0.7624762642660873,0.7637036102626152,0.7648943579005636,0.7660509266859915,0.767175517717723],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.8306452412091073,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.7349358566225721,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.3723829346122407}}},{"q":0.7,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"owners_only","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":4.3428372009657323e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.7,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"per_capita","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":3.7971403799019754e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.084084093991855,4.204788749303875,4.144619216321379,4.046736421070163,3.908159233474705,3.7290781300551132,3.509682380554896,3.2502746468704307,2.951261629899702,2.613139850591132,2.637769101434455,2.6491345109212863,2.6603524645583394,2.6710700070740225,2.6813367229207277,2.6911864337790457,2.7006498808179127,2.70975480369338,2.7185263104949557,2.726987186726242],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9972903288753227,0.9973145912462654,0.9972243776951589,0.9971074724553763,0.9969560008107066,0.9967611619315175,0.9965096317514044,0.9961808342236825,0.9957415793215795,0.9951350026642908,0.995180208943464,0.99520078774126,0.9952209279477915,0.9952400124725879,0.995258151823569,0.9952754249368964,0.9952919025497716,0.9953076477816618,0.9953227171547108,0.995337161441316],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9961023066663831,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9951350026642908,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6381012342099043},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3494343991252755,3.3981560718622053,3.305839217681976,3.1801946700979644,3.019837130275953,2.824708704792248,2.5945605870540334,2.3290285546586,2.027663326639404,1.6899645392375213,1.7095355939732904,1.7178065520054442,1.7261616355983196,1.7342844925089658,1.7422004338668406,1.7499233835728103,1.7574662615653576,1.7648408398986706,1.772057875995761,1.77912722139671],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.996697964433607,0.9966792627825882,0.9965225769103107,0.9963222131286181,0.9960640954674088,0.9957286325139143,0.9952843569302511,0.9946782045629766,0.9938138728872116,0.992497344264752,0.992582598852793,0.9926180487921938,0.9926535169143249,0.9926876739815556,0.9927206567461891,0.9927525498937418,0.9927834307860599,0.9928133692866642,0.9928424286859866,0.9928706664666508],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9945477237558398,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.992497344264752,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5028861639036438}}},{"q":0.7,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"displacement_cohorts","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":4.069988790433854e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.039697722561884,4.159500826660024,4.0984755487608915,3.999779410368186,3.8604282061128052,3.680609627592343,3.4605104165179195,3.200430934690873,2.900775785728137,2.5620395742389808,2.5866688250823033,2.598034234569135,2.609252188206188,2.619969730721871,2.630236446568576,2.6400861574268943,2.6495496044657614,2.6586545273412288,2.6674260341428044,2.67588691037409],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9864516443766126,0.9865729562313265,0.9861218884757943,0.9855373622768818,0.984780004053533,0.9838058096575878,0.982548158757021,0.9809041711184134,0.978707896607897,0.9756750133214545,0.97590104471732,0.9760039387063005,0.9761046397389584,0.9762000623629392,0.9762907591178451,0.9763771246844822,0.9764595127488587,0.9765382389083092,0.9766135857735546,0.9766858072065799],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9805115333319159,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9756750133214545,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6256230848290364},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3050480276953045,3.352868149218355,3.2596955501214886,3.133237659395988,2.9721061029140534,2.776240202329477,2.5453886230170575,2.279184842479043,1.9771774824678392,1.6388642628853693,1.6584353176211388,1.6667062756532927,1.675061359246168,1.683184216156814,1.691100157514689,1.6988231072206585,1.7063659852132056,1.7137405635465193,1.7209575996436093,1.7280269450445584],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9834898221680354,0.9833963139129408,0.9826128845515537,0.9816110656430913,0.9803204773370442,0.9786431625695714,0.9764217846512558,0.9733910228148837,0.969069364436058,0.9624867213237592,0.9629129942639651,0.9630902439609699,0.9632675845716245,0.9634383699077778,0.9636032837309456,0.9637627494687092,0.9639171539302986,0.9640668464333219,0.9642121434299328,0.9643533323332546],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9727386187791994,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9624867213237592,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.4876801513794141}}},{"q":0.7,"tax_timing":"december","policy":"owners_only","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":3.6834535421803594e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.7,"tax_timing":"december","policy":"per_capita","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":5.047695594839752e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.032248798636785,4.151900604347821,4.090731715277556,3.99189908158256,3.852417981797746,3.672475640154819,3.45225837411033,3.192066159463508,2.892303247865435,2.5534639223252116,2.5780931731685346,2.5894585826553658,2.600676536292419,2.6113940788081016,2.6216607946548067,2.631510505513125,2.640973952551992,2.650078875427459,2.6588503822290352,2.667311258460321],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.984632695593957,0.9847702942997536,0.984258667966662,0.9835956655860272,0.9827366274351147,0.9816316415424126,0.9802051433929116,0.9783404404588787,0.9758493027960852,0.9724092365632278,0.9726656140426906,0.972782322172752,0.9728965429288257,0.9730047766178944,0.9731076499613484,0.9732056106282813,0.9732990597891901,0.9733883554122619,0.9734738180504194,0.9735557356481555],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9778950886719793,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9724092365632278,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6235290009363994},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.2975991037702057,3.3452679269061516,3.2519517166381533,3.125357330610362,2.964095878598994,2.7681062148919535,2.5371365806094683,2.2708200672516776,1.9687049446051377,1.6302886109716002,1.6498596657073694,1.658130623739523,1.6664857073323986,1.6746085642430448,1.6825245056009197,1.6902474553068891,1.6977903332994364,1.7051649116327496,1.71238194772984,1.7194512931307893],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9812732308189689,0.9811671685144013,0.9802785590172984,0.9791422398539976,0.9776783822528826,0.9757758778211263,0.9732562664660266,0.9698186065007574,0.9649167393153629,0.9574503365049423,0.9579338391686082,0.958134885710747,0.9583360353722441,0.9585297496739431,0.9587168041764845,0.9588976791551658,0.9590728133506988,0.9592426029786951,0.9594074069769273,0.9595675513454702],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.969078613272739,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9574503365049423,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.4851282773052788}}},{"q":0.7,"tax_timing":"december","policy":"displacement_cohorts","receipt_schedule_supported":false,"max_collection_gap":0.009454422521872452,"first_collection_gap_month":"0010-12","max_cash_error":4.092726157978177e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":12},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.7805212457865336,3.895060101879758,3.829038043541779,3.72559271293017,3.58172194772801,3.397597178090872,3.173390384295092,2.9093884976562583,2.6059838755568037,2.263659932909376,2.2882891837526986,2.29965459323953,2.310872546876583,2.321590089392266,2.3318568052389708,2.341706516097289,2.3511699631361562,2.3602748860116236,2.3690463928131993,2.3775072690444854],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9231634779697844,0.9238514714987677,0.92129333983331,0.9179783279301358,0.913683137175573,0.9081582077120629,0.9010257169645576,0.8917022022943943,0.8792465139804257,0.8620461828161385,0.8633280702134519,0.8639116108637598,0.8644827146441278,0.8650238830894723,0.8655382498067414,0.8660280531414054,0.8664952989459499,0.8669417770613096,0.8673690902520971,0.867778678240777],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.8894754433598966,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.8620461828161385,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5527619184615117},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.045871550919954,3.0884274244380885,2.990258044902376,2.8590509619579723,2.6933998445292575,2.4932277528280067,2.25826859079423,1.9880254445474475,1.655957064888028,1.2277241377953734,1.2457686194236297,1.3099738691807068,1.3190467471414749,1.3276147022246743,1.3359258229148294,1.3440372964051546,1.3519612604487923,1.3597099444909138,1.3672944967538292,1.3747251325949081],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9063661540948443,0.9058358425720068,0.9013927950864934,0.895711199269988,0.8883919112644131,0.8788793891056316,0.8662813323301328,0.849043081010156,0.8116303541963608,0.7210287067925162,0.7233123768794029,0.7569558425987379,0.7585363766183681,0.7599138182851013,0.7612219205712621,0.7624884984588761,0.76371579232634,0.7649064894260463,0.7660630091572149,0.7671875525216363],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.8286197097685749,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.7210287067925162,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.3653363533097476}}},{"q":0.75,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"owners_only","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":4.4565240386873484e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.75,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"per_capita","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":3.9108272176235914e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.08329148021632,4.2039800363995194,4.143795222257799,4.045897903021913,3.907306893700386,3.7282126210825632,3.5088043097685215,3.24938458058151,2.9503600969680663,2.6122273456562723,2.6368565964995954,2.6482220059864265,2.6594399596234797,2.670157502139163,2.6804242179858675,2.690273928844186,2.699737375883053,2.7088422987585203,2.717613805560096,2.726074681791382],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9970967809378457,0.9971227763352841,0.9970261189590988,0.9969008633450461,0.9967385722971858,0.9965298163551972,0.9962603197336477,0.9959080366682312,0.9954374064159779,0.9947875028545973,0.9948359381537115,0.9948579868656356,0.9948795656583481,0.994900013363487,0.9949194483823953,0.9949379552895319,0.9949556098747553,0.9949724797660663,0.9949886255229045,0.9950041015442672],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9958238999996962,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9947875028545973,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6378784101138174},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3486417853497406,3.397347358957851,3.3050152236183963,3.179356152049715,3.018984790501633,2.8238431958196983,2.593682516267659,2.32813848836968,2.026761793707769,1.6890520343026612,1.7086230890384306,1.7168940470705842,1.7252491306634599,1.733371987574106,1.7412879289319805,1.7490108786379504,1.7565537566304974,1.7639283349638109,1.771145371060901,1.77821471646185],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9964621047502933,0.9964420672670589,0.9962741895467615,0.9960595140663766,0.9957829594293666,0.9954235348363367,0.9949475252824119,0.9942980763174751,0.9933720066648696,0.9919614402836626,0.9920527844851355,0.9920907665630648,0.9921287681224911,0.9921653649802381,0.992200703656631,0.9922348748861519,0.9922679615564926,0.992300038521426,0.9923311735921284,0.9923614283571258],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9941582754526855,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9919614402836626,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5026146279657111}}},{"q":0.75,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"displacement_cohorts","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":5.002220859751105e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.035734653684207,4.155457262138252,4.09435557844299,3.9955868201269373,3.8561665072412064,3.676282082729595,3.456120062586046,3.19598060324627,2.8962681210699617,2.5574770495646817,2.5821063004080043,2.5934717098948354,2.6046896635318886,2.6154072060475713,2.6256739218942764,2.635523632752595,2.644987079791462,2.6540920026669292,2.662863509468505,2.671324385699791],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9854839046892274,0.985613881676421,0.9851305947954937,0.9845043167252304,0.983692861485928,0.9826490817759866,0.9813015986682365,0.9795401833411573,0.9771870320798897,0.973937514272987,0.9741796907685573,0.974289934328179,0.974397828291741,0.9745000668174347,0.9745972419119768,0.9746897764476594,0.9747780493737771,0.9748623988303311,0.9749431276145227,0.9750205077213356],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9791194999984811,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.973937514272987,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6245089643486018},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3010849588176283,3.3488245846965827,3.2555755798035877,3.1290450691547393,2.967844404042455,2.77191265746673,2.540998269085185,2.2747345110344392,1.9726698178096638,1.6343017382110703,1.6538727929468395,1.6621437509789931,1.6704988345718688,1.6786216914825152,1.6865376328403898,1.694260582546359,1.7018034605389065,1.70917803887222,1.7163950749693102,1.7234644203702594],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9823105237514664,0.9822103363352938,0.9813709477338075,0.9802975703318834,0.978914797146833,0.9771176741816836,0.9747376264120599,0.9714903815873753,0.9668600333243478,0.9598072014183137,0.9602639224256769,0.9604538328153247,0.9606438406124549,0.9608268249011906,0.9610035182831561,0.9611743744307598,0.961339807782463,0.9615001926071306,0.9616558679606424,0.96180714178563],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.970791377263428,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9598072014183137,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.48632247168975085}}},{"q":0.75,"tax_timing":"december","policy":"owners_only","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":3.54702933691442e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.75,"tax_timing":"december","policy":"per_capita","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":2.7057467377744615e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.027753663764459,4.147314166803748,4.086058613996561,3.9871436107137668,3.8475841240465,3.6675670961893907,3.4472785885779147,3.1870183440740925,2.887190401931352,2.5482888510856427,2.5729181019289658,2.584283511415797,2.59550146505285,2.6062190075685328,2.616485723415238,2.6263354342735563,2.6357988813124233,2.6449038041878907,2.6536753109894664,2.6621361872207525],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9835350309935253,0.9836824581783074,0.983134287107138,0.9824239274136005,0.9815035293947655,0.9803196159382991,0.9787912250638338,0.9767933290630842,0.9741242529958055,0.9704384677463153,0.9707131579028826,0.9708382023279484,0.9709605817094559,0.9710765463763154,0.9711867678157302,0.9712917256731584,0.9713918497741321,0.9714875236559949,0.9715790907683064,0.9716668596230237],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9763161664342634,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9704384677463153,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6222653030350621},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.2931039688978796,3.3406814893620793,3.247278615357158,3.120601859741569,2.9592620208477487,2.763197670926526,2.532156795077053,2.2657722518622623,1.9635920986710544,1.6251135397320318,1.6446845944678008,1.6529555524999546,1.66131063609283,1.6694334930034764,1.6773494343613509,1.6850723840673205,1.692615262059868,1.6999898403931812,1.7072068764902717,1.7142762218912204],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9799356044488952,0.97982196626543,0.9788698846613914,0.9776523998435688,0.9760839809852314,0.9740455833797781,0.9713459997850284,0.9676627926793828,0.9624107921236028,0.9544110748267239,0.9549291133949372,0.9551445204043719,0.9553600378988328,0.9555675889363677,0.9557680044748046,0.9559617990948204,0.9561494428757488,0.9563313603343162,0.9565079360467079,0.9566795192987179],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9668699427922204,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9544110748267239,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.4835883208960344}}},{"q":0.75,"tax_timing":"december","policy":"displacement_cohorts","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":4.75210981676355e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":11},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.758045571424904,3.872127914159395,3.805672537136799,3.701815358586207,3.557552658971783,3.3730544582637334,3.1484914566330167,2.8841494207091825,2.5804196458863897,2.237784576711533,2.262413827554856,2.273779237041687,2.2849971906787405,2.295714733194423,2.305981449041128,2.3158311598994463,2.3252946069383134,2.334399529813781,2.343171036615357,2.351631912846643],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9176751549676261,0.9184122908915369,0.9156714355356894,0.9121196370680028,0.9075176469738283,0.9015980796914959,0.8939561253191686,0.8839666453154225,0.8706212649790274,0.852192338731577,0.8535657895144129,0.8541910116397424,0.8548029085472799,0.8553827318815773,0.8559338390786514,0.8564586283657913,0.8569592488706604,0.8574376182799746,0.8578954538415327,0.8583342981151183],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.8815808321713177,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.852192338731577,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5464434289548251},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.0233958765583244,3.065495236717726,2.9668925384973956,2.8352736076140084,2.669230555773031,2.468685033000868,2.233369663132155,1.9628620848312126,1.6566770456662494,1.2685797691713185,1.2553612824230305,1.3116633398151316,1.3190625320009295,1.3276314987833169,1.3359437328150632,1.3440562826654485,1.3519812926180192,1.359730994203927,1.3673160619465274,1.374746697787606],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.899678022244476,0.8991098313271503,0.8943494233069571,0.8882619992178441,0.8804199049261568,0.8702279168988908,0.8567299989251422,0.8382963491106041,0.8119832366873582,0.745022763885087,0.7288820242172125,0.7579320870091907,0.7585454539237192,0.7599234324728553,0.7612321257850692,0.7624992695923422,0.7637271083931836,0.7649183309678029,0.7660750916284387,0.7671995873255496],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.8255745258259441,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.7288820242172125,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.3735603943001718}}},{"q":0.8,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"owners_only","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":3.728928277269006e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.8,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"per_capita","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":3.183231456205249e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.082498866440785,4.203171323495165,4.142971228194218,4.045059384973664,3.906454553926066,3.7273471121100146,3.5079262389821464,3.24849451429259,2.9494585640364317,2.6113148407214126,2.6359440915647356,2.647309501051567,2.65852745468862,2.6692449972043026,2.6795117130510078,2.689361423909326,2.6988248709481932,2.70792979382366,2.7167013006252363,2.7251621768565224],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9969032330003688,0.9969309614243032,0.9968278602230387,0.9966942542347159,0.9965211437836647,0.9962984707788773,0.9960110077158907,0.9956352391127802,0.9951332335103765,0.9944400030449038,0.994491667363959,0.9945151859900114,0.9945382033689047,0.994560014254386,0.9945807449412217,0.9946004856421674,0.9946193171997391,0.9946373117504705,0.9946545338910981,0.9946710416472183],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9955454933330093,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9944400030449038,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6376555860177305},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3478491715742056,3.3965386460534965,3.3041912295548164,3.1785176340014654,3.0181324507273137,2.822977686847149,2.592804445481285,2.327248422080759,2.025860260776134,1.6881395293678017,1.7077105841035707,1.7159815421357245,1.7243366257286,1.7324594826392463,1.7403754239971208,1.7480983737030904,1.755641251695638,1.7630158300289511,1.7702328661260416,1.7773022115269903],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9962262450669795,0.9962048717515294,0.9960258021832123,0.9957968150041351,0.9955018233913243,0.9951184371587591,0.9946106936345729,0.9939179480719735,0.9929301404425275,0.9914255363025737,0.9915229701174777,0.9915634843339358,0.991604019330657,0.9916430559789208,0.9916807505670732,0.991717199878562,0.9917524923269255,0.9917867077561878,0.9918199184982704,0.991852190247601],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9937688271495313,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9914255363025737,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5023430920277785}}},{"q":0.8,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"displacement_cohorts","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":5.1159076974727213e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.031771584806532,4.15141369761648,4.09023560812509,3.9913942298856897,3.8519048083696092,3.671954537866848,3.451729708654174,3.1915302718016663,2.8917604564117863,2.552914524890382,2.577543775733705,2.588909185220536,2.6001271388575895,2.610844681373272,2.6211113972199773,2.6309611080782958,2.6404245551171623,2.64952947799263,2.658300984794206,2.666761861025492],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9845161650018428,0.984654807121516,0.9841393011151934,0.9834712711735792,0.9826057189183236,0.9814923538943859,0.9800550385794525,0.9781761955639011,0.9756661675518823,0.9722000152245194,0.9724583368197944,0.9725759299500575,0.9726910168445239,0.9728000712719305,0.9729037247061088,0.9730024282108367,0.9730965859986955,0.9731865587523532,0.973272669455491,0.9733552082360915],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9777274666650467,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9722000152245194,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6233948438681671},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.2971218899399526,3.3447810201748105,3.2514556094856872,3.1248524789134917,2.963582705170857,2.7675851126039825,2.536607915153312,2.2702841795898356,1.9681621531514886,1.6297392135367712,1.6493102682725405,1.6575812263046943,1.6659363098975697,1.6740591668082156,1.6819751081660905,1.6896980578720604,1.6972409358646074,1.7046155141979207,1.7118325502950111,1.71890189569596],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9811312253348976,0.9810243587576467,0.9801290109160614,0.9789840750206756,0.9775091169566219,0.9755921857937958,0.9730534681728639,0.9695897403598669,0.9646507022126377,0.957127681512868,0.9576148505873888,0.95781742166968,0.9580200966532854,0.9582152798946032,0.9584037528353665,0.9585859993928108,0.9587624616346273,0.9589335387809392,0.9590995924913519,0.9592609512380054],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9688441357476566,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.957127681512868,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.4849647920000875}}},{"q":0.8,"tax_timing":"december","policy":"owners_only","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":4.206412995699793e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.8,"tax_timing":"december","policy":"per_capita","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":4.0472514228895307e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.023258528892133,4.142727729259676,4.081385512715564,3.9823881398449736,3.842750266295255,3.662658552223963,3.4422988030454995,3.181970528684678,2.88207755599727,2.543113779846075,2.5677430306893974,2.5791084401762285,2.5903263938132817,2.6010439363289644,2.6113106521756695,2.6211603630339875,2.630623810072855,2.6397287329483223,2.648500239749898,2.656961115981184],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9824373663930936,0.9825946220568611,0.9820099062476138,0.9812521892411737,0.9802704313544166,0.9790075903341856,0.977377306734756,0.9752462176672901,0.972399203195526,0.9684676989294032,0.9687607017630748,0.968894082483145,0.9690246204900863,0.9691483161347364,0.9692658856701123,0.9693778407180355,0.9694846397590742,0.969586691899728,0.9696843634861936,0.9697779835978919],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9747372441965477,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9684676989294032,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6210016051337249},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.2886088340255535,3.336095051818006,3.242605514076161,3.115846388872776,2.9544281630965035,2.7582891269610985,2.5271770095446384,2.2607244364728474,1.9584792527369719,1.6199384684924634,1.6395095232282322,1.6477804812603862,1.6561355648532619,1.6642584217639078,1.6721743631217827,1.6798973128277521,1.6874401908202996,1.6948147691536126,1.7020318052507033,1.7091011506516522],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9785979780788214,0.9784767640164586,0.9774612103054839,0.97616255983314,0.9744895797175802,0.9723152889384301,0.9694357331040304,0.9655069788580084,0.959904844931843,0.9513718131485056,0.9519243876212664,0.9521541550979967,0.9523840404254219,0.9526054281987921,0.9528192047731251,0.9530259190344751,0.9532260724007987,0.9534201176899373,0.9536084651164884,0.9537914872519659],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9646612723117018,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9513718131485056,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.48204836448678995}}},{"q":0.8,"tax_timing":"december","policy":"displacement_cohorts","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":5.070432962384075e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":10},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.7355698970632734,3.849195726439032,3.7823070307318183,3.678038004242243,3.5333833702155557,3.3485117384365948,3.123592528970942,2.8589103437621066,2.5548554162159767,2.2119092205136908,2.236538471357014,2.247903880843845,2.259121834480898,2.269839376996581,2.280106092843286,2.2899558037016043,2.2994192507404714,2.3085241736159388,2.3172956804175144,2.3257565566488005],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9121868319654676,0.9129731102843058,0.9100495312380685,0.9062609462058695,0.9013521567720832,0.8950379516709288,0.8868865336737799,0.8762310883364507,0.8619960159776294,0.8423384946470154,0.8438035088153737,0.8444704124157255,0.8451231024504319,0.8457415806736824,0.8463294283505617,0.8468892035901777,0.8474231987953714,0.8479334594986395,0.8484218174309681,0.8488899179894595],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.8736862209827388,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.8423384946470154,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5401249394481387},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.0009202021966948,3.042563048997364,2.943527032092416,2.8114962532700454,2.6450612670168048,2.4441423131737303,2.2084707354700805,1.9376642515502764,1.631231297614372,1.2886156765791672,1.3020894677217403,1.3116705274140754,1.319069719599873,1.3276386863822598,1.335950920414006,1.3440634702643923,1.351988480216963,1.3597381818028709,1.367323725240346,1.374755327695023],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.8929898903941078,0.8923838200822938,0.887306051527421,0.8808127991657005,0.8724478985879007,0.8615764446921503,0.8471786655201518,0.8275348942900416,0.7995115718464988,0.756789629065108,0.7560131256502447,0.7579362402943385,0.7585495872535433,0.7599275465849903,0.7612362213402099,0.7625033472035371,0.7637311686299544,0.7649223743603645,0.7660793851920688,0.7672044033846969],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.8222726081504108,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.7560131256502447,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.38345597158705647}}},{"q":0.85,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"owners_only","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":3.296918293926865e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.85,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"per_capita","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":3.5697667044587433e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.081706252665249,4.20236261059081,4.142147234130638,4.044220866925414,3.9056022141517452,3.726481603137464,3.5070481681957713,3.2476044480036688,2.948557031104796,2.610402335786553,2.635031586629876,2.6463969961167066,2.6576149497537602,2.668332492269443,2.678599208116148,2.6884489189744665,2.697912366013333,2.707017288888801,2.7157887956903766,2.7242496719216627],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9967096850628917,0.996739146513322,0.9966296014869785,0.9964876451243856,0.9963037152701435,0.9960671252025569,0.9957616956981337,0.9953624415573289,0.9948290606047749,0.9940925032352104,0.9941473965742065,0.9941723851143871,0.9941968410794613,0.9942200151452852,0.9942420415000481,0.9942630159948029,0.9942830245247226,0.9943021437348751,0.9943204422592918,0.9943379817501695],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9952670866663224,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9940925032352104,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6374327619216436},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3470565577986697,3.3957299331491413,3.303367235491235,3.177679115953216,3.017280110952994,2.8221121778745992,2.59192637469491,2.3263583557918386,2.024958727844499,1.687227024432942,1.7067980791687107,1.7150690372008648,1.72342412079374,1.7315469777043864,1.7394629190622612,1.7471858687682307,1.7547287467607782,1.7621033250940912,1.7693203611911819,1.7763897065921308],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9959903853836656,0.9959676762359998,0.9957774148196628,0.9955341159418936,0.9952206873532821,0.9948133394811816,0.9942738619867336,0.9935378198264718,0.9924882742201857,0.9908896323214846,0.99099315574982,0.9910362021048069,0.991079270538823,0.9911207469776032,0.9911607974775155,0.9911995248709722,0.9912370230973585,0.9912733769909495,0.9913086634044125,0.9913429521380762],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.993379378846377,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9908896323214846,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5020715560898459}}},{"q":0.85,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"displacement_cohorts","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":4.661160346586257e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.0278085159288555,4.147370133094707,4.086115637807189,3.987201639644441,3.8476431094980104,3.6676269930041006,3.4473393547223004,3.1870799403570627,2.887252791753611,2.5483520002160827,2.5729812510594057,2.584346660546237,2.59556461418329,2.606282156698973,2.6165488725456783,2.6263985834039962,2.6358620304428633,2.6449669533183306,2.6537384601199068,2.6621993363511924],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9835484253144579,0.9836957325666106,0.983148007434893,0.9824382256219277,0.9815185763507186,0.980335626012785,0.9788084784906681,0.9768122077866449,0.9741453030238749,0.9704625161760517,0.9707369828710315,0.9708619255719362,0.9709842053973066,0.9711000757264262,0.9712102075002406,0.9713150799740139,0.9714151226236141,0.9715107186743752,0.9716022112964592,0.971689908750847],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.976335433331612,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9704625161760517,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6222807233877324},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.293158821062277,3.340737455653038,3.247335639167786,3.120659888672243,2.9593210062992585,2.763257567741235,2.532217561221439,2.2658338481452325,1.963654488493313,1.625176688862472,1.644747743598241,1.6530187016303948,1.6613737852232706,1.6694966421339164,1.6774125834917912,1.6851355331977609,1.6926784111903082,1.7000529895236216,1.7072700256207118,1.7143393710216608],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9799519269183288,0.9798383811799994,0.9788870740983151,0.9776705797094677,0.9761034367664108,0.9740666974059081,0.9713693099336678,0.9676890991323587,0.9624413711009275,0.9544481616074222,0.9549657787491005,0.9551810105240348,0.9553963526941157,0.9556037348880159,0.9558039873875769,0.9559976243548614,0.9561851154867914,0.9563668849547481,0.9565433170220614,0.9567147606903806],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9668968942318851,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9544481616074222,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.4836071123104242}}},{"q":0.85,"tax_timing":"december","policy":"owners_only","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":3.501554601825774e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.85,"tax_timing":"december","policy":"per_capita","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":4.3428372009657323e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.018763394019807,4.138141291715604,4.076712411434569,3.977632668976182,3.83791640854401,3.6577500082585357,3.4373190175130848,3.176922713295262,2.876964710063187,2.537938708606506,2.562567959449829,2.57393336893666,2.5851513225737133,2.595868865089396,2.606135580936101,2.6159852917944195,2.6254487388332866,2.634553661708754,2.64332516851033,2.6517860447416153],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.981339701792662,0.9815067859354152,0.9808855253880897,0.9800804510687473,0.9790373333140677,0.9776955647300724,0.9759633884056783,0.9736991062714956,0.9706741533952463,0.9664969301124907,0.9668082456232671,0.9669499626383417,0.9670886592707167,0.9672200858931574,0.9673450035244944,0.9674639557629129,0.9675774297440164,0.967685860143461,0.9677896362040809,0.96788910757276],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.973158321958832,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9664969301124907,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6197379072323875},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.284113699153228,3.3315086142739343,3.237932412795166,3.111090918003984,2.9495943053452582,2.753380582995671,2.5221972240122232,2.255676621083432,1.9533664068028893,1.6147633972528947,1.6343344519886638,1.6426054100208176,1.650960493613693,1.6590833505243392,1.666999291882214,1.6747222415881837,1.682265119580731,1.689639697914044,1.6968567340111347,1.7039260794120836],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9772603517087479,0.9771315617674874,0.976052535949577,0.9746727198227114,0.972895178449929,0.970584994497082,0.9675254664230322,0.9633511650366339,0.9573988977400834,0.9483325514702872,0.9489196618475956,0.9491637897916215,0.9494080429520105,0.9496432674612166,0.9498704050714454,0.9500900389741299,0.9503027019258485,0.9505088750455583,0.950708994186269,0.9509034552052138],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9624526018311832,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9483325514702872,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.4805084080775454}}},{"q":0.85,"tax_timing":"december","policy":"displacement_cohorts","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":5.911715561524034e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.7130942227016446,3.8262635387186696,3.758941524326838,3.65426064989828,3.50921408145933,3.323969018609457,3.0986936013088666,2.833671266815031,2.529291186545563,2.1860338643158483,2.210663115159171,2.222028524646002,2.2332464782830552,2.2439640207987384,2.2542307366454435,2.264080447503762,2.2735438945426285,2.282648817418096,2.291420324219672,2.2998812004509577],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9066985089633094,0.907533929677075,0.9044276269404478,0.9004022553437364,0.8951866665703386,0.888477823650362,0.8798169420283909,0.8684955313574788,0.8533707669762313,0.8324846505624539,0.8340412281163344,0.8347498131917082,0.8354432963535837,0.8361004294657877,0.8367250176224718,0.8373197788145638,0.837887148720082,0.8384293007173044,0.8389481810204037,0.8394455378638006],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.86579160979416,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.8324846505624539,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5338064499414523},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[2.978444527835065,3.019630861277,2.9201615256874356,2.787718898926082,2.6208919782605777,2.419599593346592,2.183571807808006,1.9124251746032002,1.6056928832852657,1.2628440846837194,1.2823301552388422,1.2906625928370987,1.2990556493230356,1.3071785062336818,1.3150944475915567,1.3228173972975263,1.3303602752900736,1.3377348536233868,1.3449518897204773,1.3520212351214262],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.8863017585437395,0.8856578088374369,0.8802626797478849,0.8733635991135568,0.8644758922496444,0.8529249724854098,0.8376273321151614,0.8167558251831689,0.7869944887004166,0.7416542602926678,0.7445405656140798,0.7457970066858695,0.7470402147600531,0.7482163373060834,0.7493520253572272,0.7504501948706498,0.7515135096292426,0.7525443752277923,0.7535449709313445,0.7545172760260691],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.8122596649865673,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.7416542602926678,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.37578706689403885}}},{"q":0.9,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"owners_only","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":3.660716174636036e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.9,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"per_capita","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":4.229150363244116e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.080913638889713,4.201553897686456,4.1413232400670585,4.043382348877165,3.9047498743774263,3.7256160941649146,3.5061700974093966,3.2467143817147486,2.9476554981731615,2.609489830851693,2.634119081695016,2.6454844911818474,2.6567024448189005,2.667419987334583,2.677686703181288,2.6875364140396063,2.696999861078474,2.706104783953941,2.714876290755517,2.723337166986803],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9965161371254145,0.9965473316023411,0.9964313427509186,0.9962810360140554,0.9960862867566228,0.9958357796262367,0.9955123836803768,0.9950896440018777,0.9945248876991736,0.9937450034255169,0.993803125784454,0.993829584238763,0.9938554787900179,0.9938800160361844,0.9939033380588743,0.9939255463474382,0.9939467318497065,0.9939669757192796,0.9939863506274855,0.9940049218531207],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9949886799996355,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9937450034255169,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6372099378255567},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3462639440231343,3.394921220244787,3.302543241427655,3.1768405979049663,3.016427771178675,2.8212466689020497,2.5910483039085355,2.325468289502918,2.0240571949128636,1.6863145194980818,1.705885574233851,1.7141565322660048,1.7225116158588802,1.7306344727695262,1.738550414127401,1.746273363833371,1.753816241825918,1.7611908201592312,1.768407856256322,1.7754772016572709],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9957545257003517,0.9957304807204704,0.9955290274561136,0.995271416879652,0.99493955131524,0.994508241803604,0.9939370303388944,0.9931576915809702,0.9920464079978435,0.9903537283403953,0.9904633413821625,0.9905089198756779,0.9905545217469892,0.9905984379762857,0.9906408443879574,0.9906818498633824,0.9907215538677911,0.9907600462257112,0.9907974083105543,0.9908337140285512],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9929899305432226,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9903537283403953,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.501800020151913}}},{"q":0.9,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"displacement_cohorts","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":5.866240826435387e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.02384544705118,4.143326568572935,4.081995667489289,3.9830090494031936,3.843381410626413,3.6632994481413537,3.4429490007904278,3.1826296089124595,2.882745127095435,2.5437894755417836,2.5684187263851066,2.579784135871938,2.5910020895089914,2.601719632024674,2.6119863478713787,2.6218360587296967,2.631299505768564,2.6404044286440316,2.6491759354456077,2.6576368116768934],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9825806856270731,0.9827366580117053,0.9821567137545927,0.9814051800702766,0.980431433783114,0.9791788981311843,0.977561918401884,0.9754482200093888,0.9726244384958673,0.9687250171275843,0.9690156289222687,0.9691479211938149,0.9692773939500895,0.9694000801809219,0.9695166902943723,0.9696277317371912,0.9697336592485326,0.9698348785963973,0.9699317531374274,0.9700246092656029],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9749433999981776,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9687250171275843,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6211666029072979},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.2891957521846007,3.336693891131266,3.2432156688498854,3.1164672984309956,2.95505930742766,2.7589300228784883,2.5278272072895662,2.2613835167006293,1.959146823835138,1.6206141641881726,1.6401852189239419,1.6484561769560955,1.656811260548971,1.6649341174596173,1.6728500588174922,1.6805730085234616,1.6881158865160089,1.695490464849322,1.7027075009464125,1.7097768463473617],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9787726285017598,0.9786524036023525,0.977645137280569,0.9763570843982601,0.9746977565761995,0.9725412090180205,0.9696851516944719,0.9657884579048505,0.9602320399892176,0.9517686417019764,0.9523167069108124,0.9525445993783898,0.952772608734946,0.9529921898814286,0.9532042219397874,0.953409249316912,0.9536077693389556,0.9538002311285566,0.9539870415527709,0.9541685701427561],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9649496527161135,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9517686417019764,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.4822494326207608}}},{"q":0.9,"tax_timing":"december","policy":"owners_only","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":3.3651303965598345e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.9,"tax_timing":"december","policy":"per_capita","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":4.411049303598702e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.014268259147481,4.133554854171531,4.072039310153572,3.9728771981073887,3.8330825507927644,3.6528414642931075,3.43233923198067,3.1718748979058473,2.871851864129104,2.532763637366937,2.55739288821026,2.5687582976970913,2.5799762513341444,2.5906937938498276,2.6009605096965323,2.6108102205548507,2.6202736675937177,2.629378590469185,2.6381500972707608,2.646610973502047],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9802420371922302,0.9804189498139689,0.9797611445285654,0.9789087128963206,0.9778042352737187,0.9763835391259588,0.9745494700766006,0.9721519948757013,0.9689491035949667,0.9645261612955783,0.9648557894834591,0.9650058427935381,0.9651526980513471,0.9652918556515786,0.9654241213788762,0.96555007080779,0.9656702197289584,0.9657850283871938,0.9658949089219677,0.9660002315476284],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9715793997211162,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9645261612955783,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6184742093310502},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.2796185642809017,3.326922176729861,3.2332593115141695,3.1063354471351907,2.9447604475940126,2.7484720390302426,2.5172174384798085,2.2506288056940167,1.9482535608688063,1.6095883260133261,1.6291593807490956,1.6374303387812494,1.6457854223741248,1.6539082792847708,1.6618242206426457,1.6695471703486153,1.6770900483411624,1.684464626674476,1.691681662771566,1.6987510081725152],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9759227253386742,0.9757863595185159,0.9746438615936696,0.9731828798122825,0.9713007771822776,0.9688547000557337,0.9656151997420342,0.9611953512152593,0.9548929505483233,0.9452932897920686,0.945914936073925,0.9461734244852464,0.9464320454785996,0.9466811067236411,0.9469216053697658,0.9471541589137846,0.9473793314508984,0.9475976324011797,0.9478095232560494,0.9480154231584617],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9602439313506644,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9452932897920686,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.47896845166830093}}},{"q":0.9,"tax_timing":"december","policy":"displacement_cohorts","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":5.547917680814862e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.690618548340015,3.803331350998307,3.7355760179218582,3.630483295554317,3.4850447927031034,3.299426298782319,3.073794673646793,2.8084321898679554,2.5037269568751497,2.160158508118006,2.184787758961329,2.19615316844816,2.2073711220852132,2.218088664600896,2.228355380447601,2.2382050913059195,2.2476685383447865,2.256773461220254,2.26554496802183,2.2740058442531152],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9012101859611511,0.9020947490698442,0.8988057226428271,0.8945435644816033,0.8890211763685938,0.881917695629795,0.8727473503830026,0.8607599743785072,0.8447455179748331,0.8226308064778923,0.8242789474172955,0.8250292139676912,0.8257634902567359,0.8264592782578929,0.8271206068943819,0.8277503540389499,0.8283510986447928,0.8289251419359696,0.8294745446098394,0.8300011577381418],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.8578969986055812,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.8226308064778923,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5274879604347659},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[2.955968853473436,2.996698673556638,2.8967960192824553,2.763941544582119,2.5967226895043516,2.395056873519454,2.158672880145931,1.8871860976561248,1.5801286536148522,1.236983196764395,1.2565542515001638,1.2648252095323178,1.2731802931251934,1.2813031500358392,1.289219091393714,1.2969420410996837,1.3044849190922312,1.3118594974255444,1.3190765335226349,1.3261458789235836],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.8796136266933713,0.8789317975925803,0.8732193079683487,0.8659143990614131,0.8565038859113883,0.8442735002786691,0.8280759987101708,0.8059767560762967,0.7744647527416175,0.7264664489603434,0.729574680369624,0.7308671224262323,0.7321602273929976,0.7334055336182058,0.7346080268488286,0.7357707945689231,0.7368966572544922,0.7379881620058978,0.7390476162802472,0.7400771157923084],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.8012196567533231,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.7264664489603434,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.3680915902027002}}},{"q":0.95,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"owners_only","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":3.774403012357652e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.95,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"per_capita","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":5.161382432561368e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.080121025114178,4.200745184782102,4.140499246003477,4.042543830828915,3.9038975346031064,3.724750585192365,3.5052920266230223,3.2458243154258275,2.9467539652415264,2.6085773259168334,2.6332065767601565,2.6445719862469876,2.6557899398840408,2.6665074823997235,2.6767741982464286,2.6866239091047466,2.696087356143614,2.705192279019081,2.713963785820657,2.722424662051943],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9963225891879376,0.99635551669136,0.9962330840148583,0.9960744269037252,0.9958688582431018,0.9956044340499165,0.9952630716626201,0.9948168464464264,0.9942207147935721,0.9933975036158235,0.9934588549947014,0.9934867833631388,0.9935141165005745,0.9935400169270836,0.993564634617701,0.9935880767000738,0.9936104391746903,0.993631807703684,0.9936522589956792,0.9936718619560717],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9947102733329486,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9933975036158235,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6369871137294698},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.345471330247599,3.3941125073404326,3.3017192473640753,3.176002079856717,3.015575431404355,2.8203811599295006,2.590170233122161,2.3245782232139973,2.023155661981229,1.685402014563222,1.7049730692989913,1.713244027331145,1.7215991109240205,1.7297219678346667,1.7376379091925411,1.745360858898511,1.7529037368910583,1.7602783152243715,1.767495351321462,1.7745646967224111],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9955186660170379,0.9954932852049411,0.9952806400925645,0.9950087178174104,0.9946584152771978,0.9942031441260266,0.9936001986910553,0.9927775633354685,0.9916045417755016,0.9898178243593062,0.9899335270145049,0.9899816376465488,0.9900297729551554,0.9900761289749683,0.9901208912983994,0.9901641748557924,0.990206084638224,0.990246715460473,0.9902861532166961,0.9903244759190264],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9926004822400685,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9898178243593062,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5015284842139804}}},{"q":0.95,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"displacement_cohorts","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":4.3428372009657323e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.019882378173504,4.139283004051162,4.077875697171387,3.9788164591619455,3.839119711754814,3.658971903278605,3.4385586468585547,3.178179277467857,2.87823746243726,2.539226950867485,2.5638562017108075,2.575221611197639,2.5864395648346923,2.5971571073503745,2.6074238231970797,2.617273534055398,2.6267369810942656,2.6358419039697325,2.644613410771308,2.6530742870025943],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9816129459396883,0.9817775834567999,0.981165420074292,0.9803721345186253,0.979344291215509,0.978022170249583,0.9763153583130997,0.9740842322321328,0.9711035739678602,0.966987518079117,0.967294274973506,0.9674339168156937,0.9675705825028723,0.9677000846354176,0.9678231730885042,0.9679403835003687,0.9680521958734514,0.9681590385184194,0.9682612949783955,0.9683593097803587],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.973551366664743,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.966987518079117,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6200524824268633},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.285232683306924,3.3326503266094933,3.2390956985319845,3.1122747081897475,2.9507976085560625,2.7546024780157405,2.523436853357693,2.256933185256026,1.9546391591769625,1.6160516395138735,1.6356226942496426,1.6438936522817964,1.6522487358746718,1.6603715927853182,1.6682875341431926,1.6760104838491623,1.6835533618417098,1.690927940175023,1.6981449762721135,1.7052143216730622],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9775933300851907,0.9774664260247053,0.9764032004628228,0.9750435890870522,0.9732920763859886,0.9710157206301326,0.9680009934552758,0.9638878166773422,0.9580227088775074,0.9490891217965307,0.9496676350725242,0.9499081882327449,0.9501488647757762,0.9503806448748414,0.9506044564919977,0.9508208742789626,0.95103042319112,0.9512335773023655,0.9514307660834804,0.9516223795951313],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9630024112003422,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9490891217965307,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.4808917529310975}}},{"q":0.95,"tax_timing":"december","policy":"owners_only","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":4.547473508864641e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":0.95,"tax_timing":"december","policy":"per_capita","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":2.9331204132176936e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.009773124275155,4.128968416627458,4.067366208872577,3.9681217272385956,3.8282486930415187,3.6479329203276807,3.4273594464482553,3.1668270825164324,2.8667390181950214,2.527588566127369,2.5522178169706917,2.5635832264575233,2.5748011800945765,2.5855187226102587,2.595785438456964,2.6056351493152823,2.6150985963541498,2.6242035192296167,2.6329750260311924,2.6414359022624785],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9791443725917985,0.9793311136925227,0.9786367636690415,0.9777369747238939,0.9765711372333696,0.9750715135218456,0.9731355517475229,0.970604883479907,0.967224053794687,0.9625553924786662,0.9629033333436513,0.9630617229487348,0.9632167368319776,0.9633636254099994,0.9635032392332583,0.9636361858526672,0.9637630097139007,0.963884196630927,0.9640001816398548,0.9641113555224966],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9700004774834005,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9625553924786662,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6172105114297131},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.275123429408576,3.322335739185789,3.228586210233174,3.1015799762663985,2.9399265898427673,2.743563495064816,2.5122376529473933,2.245580990304602,1.943140714934724,1.6044132547737577,1.6239843095095268,1.6322552675416806,1.6406103511345562,1.6487332080452024,1.6566491494030773,1.6643720991090465,1.671914977101594,1.6792895554349074,1.6865065915319977,1.6935759369329468],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9745850989686006,0.9744411572695447,0.9732351872377625,0.971693039801854,0.9697063759146264,0.9671244056143858,0.963704933061036,0.9590395373938849,0.9523870033565637,0.9422540281138503,0.9429102103002539,0.943183059178871,0.9434560480051883,0.9437189459860658,0.9439728056680861,0.9442182788534391,0.9444559609759483,0.9446863897568006,0.9449100523258299,0.9451273911117096],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9580352608701459,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9422540281138503,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.4774284952590565}}},{"q":0.95,"tax_timing":"december","policy":"displacement_cohorts","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":3.728928277269006e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.6681428739783852,3.780399163277944,3.7122105115168784,3.6067059412103535,3.4608755039468773,3.274883578955181,3.0488957459847175,2.783193112920879,2.478162727204736,2.1342831519201635,2.1589124027634865,2.1702778122503177,2.181495765887371,2.1922133084030535,2.202480024249758,2.2123297351080766,2.221793182146944,2.230898105022411,2.239669611823987,2.248130488055273],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.8957218629589928,0.8966555684626133,0.8931838183452065,0.8886848736194702,0.8828556861668491,0.8753575676092282,0.8656777587376135,0.8530244173995352,0.8361202689734349,0.8127769623933309,0.8145166667182563,0.8153086147436741,0.816083684159888,0.816818127049998,0.8175161961662919,0.8181809292633359,0.8188150485695036,0.8194209831546343,0.8200009081992747,0.820556777612483],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.8500023874170025,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.8127769623933309,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5211694709280795},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[2.933493179111806,2.973766485836275,2.8734305128774755,2.740164190238155,2.572553400748125,2.3705141536923158,2.133773952483856,1.861947020709049,1.5545644239444385,1.211107840566552,1.2306788953023216,1.2389498533344752,1.2473049369273506,1.2554277938379972,1.2633437351958716,1.2710666849018413,1.2786095628943883,1.2859841412277018,1.293201177324792,1.3002705227257412],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.8729254948430031,0.8722057863477237,0.8661759361888126,0.8584651990092692,0.848531879573132,0.8356220280719285,0.8185246653051802,0.7951976869694243,0.7619350167828184,0.7112701405692512,0.71455105150127,0.7159152958943563,0.7172802400259417,0.7185947299303286,0.7198640283404303,0.7210913942671967,0.7222798048797415,0.7234319487840031,0.7245502616291495,0.7256369555585478],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.7901763043507297,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.7112701405692512,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.3603918081564778}}},{"q":1.0,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"owners_only","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":3.888089850079268e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":1.0,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"per_capita","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":4.206412995699793e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.079328411338643,4.199936471877747,4.139675251939898,4.041705312780666,3.9030451948287874,3.723885076219816,3.504413955836648,3.244934249136907,2.9458524323098914,2.6076648209819733,2.632294071825296,2.6436594813121275,2.6548774349491806,2.6655949774648633,2.6758616933115684,2.6857114041698864,2.695174851208754,2.7042797740842213,2.7130512808857965,2.7215121571170826],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9961290412504608,0.9961637017803788,0.9960348252787984,0.995867817793395,0.995651429729581,0.9953730884735964,0.9950137596448633,0.9945440488909751,0.9939165418879706,0.9930500038061298,0.9931145842049486,0.9931439824875143,0.9931727542111309,0.9932000178179826,0.9932259311765271,0.9932506070527091,0.9932741464996738,0.9932966396880883,0.9933181673638726,0.9933388020590228],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9944318666662616,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9930500038061298,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6367642896333828},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.344678716472065,3.393303794436078,3.3008952533004954,3.1751635618084673,3.014723091630035,2.8195156509569506,2.589292162335786,2.3236881569250762,2.0222541290495935,1.6844895096283623,1.7040605643641313,1.7123315223962852,1.7206866059891606,1.728809462899807,1.7367254042576814,1.744448353963651,1.7519912319561985,1.7593658102895118,1.7665828463866018,1.773652191787551],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9952828063337245,0.9952560896894116,0.9950322527290153,0.9947460187551689,0.9943772792391554,0.9938980464484488,0.9932633670432158,0.9923974350899667,0.9911626755531594,0.9892819203782172,0.9894037126468472,0.9894543554174199,0.9895050241633213,0.989553819973651,0.9896009382088415,0.9896464998482025,0.989690615408657,0.9897333846952349,0.9897748981228378,0.9898152378095012],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.992211033936914,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9892819203782172,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5012569482760478}}},{"q":1.0,"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"displacement_cohorts","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":5.843503458891064e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.015919309295827,4.135239439529391,4.073755726853487,3.974623868920698,3.834858012883216,3.654644358415858,3.4341682929266817,3.173728946023253,2.8737297977790845,2.5346644261931854,2.5592936770365085,2.5706590865233396,2.5818770401603928,2.5925945826760755,2.6028612985227806,2.6127110093810986,2.622174456419966,2.6312793792954334,2.640050886097009,2.648511762328295],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9806452062523033,0.9808185089018949,0.9801741263939917,0.979339088966974,0.9782571486479043,0.9768654423679822,0.9750687982243155,0.9727202444548766,0.9695827094398528,0.9652500190306493,0.9655729210247431,0.9657199124375723,0.965863771055655,0.9660000890899133,0.966129655882636,0.9662530352635459,0.9663707324983697,0.9664831984404416,0.9665908368193638,0.9666940102951144],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9721593333313084,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9652500190306493,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6189383619464286},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.281269614429249,3.3286067620877207,3.234975728214084,3.1080821179485,2.946535909684464,2.750274933152993,2.519046499425821,2.252482853811423,1.950131494518787,1.611489114839574,1.631060169575343,1.6393311276074969,1.6476862112003725,1.6558090681110187,1.6637250094688936,1.6714479591748632,1.6789908371674103,1.6863654155007237,1.693582451597814,1.7006517969987631],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9764140316686221,0.9762804484470582,0.9751612636450767,0.9737300937758446,0.9718863961957774,0.9694902322422448,0.96631683521608,0.9619871754498339,0.9558133777657973,0.9464096018910848,0.9470185632342357,0.9472717770870998,0.9475251208166066,0.947769099868254,0.9480046910442081,0.9482324992410134,0.948453077043284,0.9486669234761741,0.9488744906141898,0.9490761890475067],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9610551696845706,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9464096018910848,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.47953407324143404}}},{"q":1.0,"tax_timing":"december","policy":"owners_only","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":3.319655661471188e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.095180686849347,4.216110729964837,4.1561551332115005,4.058475673745657,3.92009199031518,3.7411952556708057,3.521975371564139,3.262735574915321,2.9638830909425926,2.6259149196791705,2.650544170522493,2.6619095800093246,2.673127533646378,2.6838450761620605,2.6941117920087656,2.7039615028670836,2.713424949905951,2.722529872781418,2.731301379582994,2.73976225581428],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6412207715551214},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.3605309919827686,3.4094780525231676,3.3173751345720985,3.191933922773459,3.031769887116428,2.8368258304079403,2.6068535780632778,2.3414894827034898,2.040284787682295,1.702739608325559,1.7223106630613283,1.7305816210934823,1.7389367046863575,1.7470595615970037,1.7549755029548786,1.7626984526608482,1.7702413306533953,1.7776159089867087,1.784832945083799,1.7919022904847481],"annual_retention_vs_control":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":1.0,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5066876670347011}}},{"q":1.0,"tax_timing":"december","policy":"per_capita","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":4.3655745685100555e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[4.005277989402829,4.1243819790833856,4.06269310759158,3.9633662563698038,3.823414835290274,3.643024376362253,3.4223796609158397,3.161779267127017,2.861626172260939,2.5224134948878003,2.5470427457311233,2.5584081552179545,2.5696261088550076,2.5803436513706908,2.590610367217396,2.600460078075714,2.609923525114581,2.6190284479900483,2.6277999547916244,2.63626083102291],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9780467079913671,0.9782432775710765,0.9775123828095172,0.9765652365514674,0.9753380391930209,0.9737594879177323,0.971721633418445,0.9690577720841126,0.9654990039944075,0.9605846236617538,0.9609508772038434,0.9611176031039312,0.9612807756126079,0.9614353951684207,0.9615823570876405,0.9617223008975445,0.9618557996988427,0.96198336487466,0.9621054543577421,0.962222479497365],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9684215552456847,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.9605846236617538,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.6159468135283757},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.27062829453625,3.317749301641717,3.2239131089521775,3.096824505397606,2.9350927320915225,2.738654951099388,2.5072578674149786,2.2405331749151864,1.9380278690006412,1.5992381835341893,1.6188092382699582,1.6270801963021122,1.6354352798949878,1.6435581368056338,1.6514740781635087,1.659197027869478,1.6667399058620256,1.6741144841953386,1.6813315202924293,1.6884008656933782],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.9732474725985268,0.9730959550205736,0.9718265128818552,0.9702031997914251,0.9681119746469753,0.9653941111730376,0.961794666380038,0.9568837235725104,0.9498810561648039,0.939214766435632,0.939905484526583,0.9401926938724959,0.9404800505317773,0.9407567852484902,0.9410240059664063,0.9412823987930939,0.9415325905009984,0.9417751471124216,0.9420105813956106,0.9422393590649574],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.9558265903896273,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.939214766435632,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.4758885388498121}}},{"q":1.0,"tax_timing":"december","policy":"displacement_cohorts","receipt_schedule_supported":true,"max_collection_gap":0.0,"first_collection_gap_month":null,"max_cash_error":4.433786671143025e-11,"liquidity_shortfall_months":{"displaced_free":0,"displaced_debt":0},"ending_private_interest_arrears":0.0,"groups":{"displaced_free":{"annual_real_consumption":[3.6456671996167556,3.7574669755575814,3.688845005111898,3.58292858686639,3.4367062151906502,3.250340859128043,3.0239968183226424,2.7579540359738033,2.4525984975343227,2.1084077957223215,2.133037046565644,2.1444024560524753,2.1556204096895284,2.1663379522052106,2.176604668051916,2.186454378910234,2.1959178259491017,2.205022748824569,2.2137942556261443,2.2222551318574304],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.8902335399568345,0.8912163878553825,0.8875619140475858,0.882826182757337,0.8766901959651041,0.8687974395886613,0.8586081670922248,0.8452888604205634,0.8274950199720368,0.8029231183087695,0.8047543860192171,0.805588015519657,0.8064038780630399,0.807176975842103,0.8079117854382022,0.808611504487722,0.8092789984942143,0.8099168243732995,0.8105272717887101,0.8111123974868243],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.8421077762284236,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.8029231183087695,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.5148509814213932},"displaced_debt":{"annual_real_consumption":[2.9110175047501765,2.950834298115912,2.850065006472495,2.716386835894192,2.548384111991899,2.3459714338651776,2.1088750248217814,1.836707943761973,1.529000194274025,1.1852324843687099,1.204803539104479,1.2130744971366327,1.2214295807295081,1.2295524376401543,1.2374683789980292,1.2451913287039986,1.2527342066965461,1.2601087850298593,1.2673258211269498,1.2743951665278987],"annual_retention_vs_control":[0.8662373629926348,0.865479775102867,0.8591325644092762,0.8510159989571257,0.8405598732348759,0.8269705558651879,0.8089733319001898,0.784418617862552,0.7494052808240194,0.6960738321781593,0.6995274226329156,0.7009634693624803,0.702400252658886,0.7037839262424509,0.7051200298320319,0.7064119939654702,0.7076629525049912,0.7088757355621086,0.7100529069780522,0.7111967953247872],"cumulative_retention_vs_control":0.7791329519481367,"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control":0.6960738321781593,"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1":0.35269202611025563}}}],"frontiers":[{"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"owners_only","floor":0.9,"metric":"cumulative_retention_vs_control","passing_q":[0.0,0.05,0.1,0.15,0.2,0.25,0.3,0.35,0.4,0.45,0.5,0.55,0.6,0.65,0.7,0.75,0.8,0.85,0.9,0.95,1.0],"minimum_passing_q":0.0,"maximum_passing_q":1.0,"passing_count":21},{"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"owners_only","floor":0.9,"metric":"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control","passing_q":[0.0,0.05,0.1,0.15,0.2,0.25,0.3,0.35,0.4,0.45,0.5,0.55,0.6,0.65,0.7,0.75,0.8,0.85,0.9,0.95,1.0],"minimum_passing_q":0.0,"maximum_passing_q":1.0,"passing_count":21},{"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"owners_only","floor":0.9,"metric":"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1","passing_q":[],"minimum_passing_q":null,"maximum_passing_q":null,"passing_count":0},{"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"owners_only","floor":0.95,"metric":"cumulative_retention_vs_control","passing_q":[0.0,0.05,0.1,0.15,0.2,0.25,0.3,0.35,0.4,0.45,0.5,0.55,0.6,0.65,0.7,0.75,0.8,0.85,0.9,0.95,1.0],"minimum_passing_q":0.0,"maximum_passing_q":1.0,"passing_count":21},{"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"owners_only","floor":0.95,"metric":"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control","passing_q":[0.0,0.05,0.1,0.15,0.2,0.25,0.3,0.35,0.4,0.45,0.5,0.55,0.6,0.65,0.7,0.75,0.8,0.85,0.9,0.95,1.0],"minimum_passing_q":0.0,"maximum_passing_q":1.0,"passing_count":21},{"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"owners_only","floor":0.95,"metric":"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1","passing_q":[],"minimum_passing_q":null,"maximum_passing_q":null,"passing_count":0},{"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"owners_only","floor":0.975,"metric":"cumulative_retention_vs_control","passing_q":[0.0,0.05,0.1,0.15,0.2,0.25,0.3,0.35,0.4,0.45,0.5,0.55,0.6,0.65,0.7,0.75,0.8,0.85,0.9,0.95,1.0],"minimum_passing_q":0.0,"maximum_passing_q":1.0,"passing_count":21},{"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"owners_only","floor":0.975,"metric":"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control","passing_q":[0.0,0.05,0.1,0.15,0.2,0.25,0.3,0.35,0.4,0.45,0.5,0.55,0.6,0.65,0.7,0.75,0.8,0.85,0.9,0.95,1.0],"minimum_passing_q":0.0,"maximum_passing_q":1.0,"passing_count":21},{"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"owners_only","floor":0.975,"metric":"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1","passing_q":[],"minimum_passing_q":null,"maximum_passing_q":null,"passing_count":0},{"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"owners_only","floor":0.99,"metric":"cumulative_retention_vs_control","passing_q":[0.0,0.05,0.1,0.15,0.2,0.25,0.3,0.35,0.4,0.45,0.5,0.55,0.6,0.65,0.7,0.75,0.8,0.85,0.9,0.95,1.0],"minimum_passing_q":0.0,"maximum_passing_q":1.0,"passing_count":21},{"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"owners_only","floor":0.99,"metric":"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control","passing_q":[0.0,0.05,0.1,0.15,0.2,0.25,0.3,0.35,0.4,0.45,0.5,0.55,0.6,0.65,0.7,0.75,0.8,0.85,0.9,0.95,1.0],"minimum_passing_q":0.0,"maximum_passing_q":1.0,"passing_count":21},{"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"owners_only","floor":0.99,"metric":"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1","passing_q":[],"minimum_passing_q":null,"maximum_passing_q":null,"passing_count":0},{"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"per_capita","floor":0.9,"metric":"cumulative_retention_vs_control","passing_q":[0.0,0.05,0.1,0.15,0.2,0.25,0.3,0.35,0.4,0.45,0.5,0.55,0.6,0.65,0.7,0.75,0.8,0.85,0.9,0.95,1.0],"minimum_passing_q":0.0,"maximum_passing_q":1.0,"passing_count":21},{"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"per_capita","floor":0.9,"metric":"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control","passing_q":[0.0,0.05,0.1,0.15,0.2,0.25,0.3,0.35,0.4,0.45,0.5,0.55,0.6,0.65,0.7,0.75,0.8,0.85,0.9,0.95,1.0],"minimum_passing_q":0.0,"maximum_passing_q":1.0,"passing_count":21},{"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"per_capita","floor":0.9,"metric":"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1","passing_q":[],"minimum_passing_q":null,"maximum_passing_q":null,"passing_count":0},{"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"per_capita","floor":0.95,"metric":"cumulative_retention_vs_control","passing_q":[0.0,0.05,0.1,0.15,0.2,0.25,0.3,0.35,0.4,0.45,0.5,0.55,0.6,0.65,0.7,0.75,0.8,0.85,0.9,0.95,1.0],"minimum_passing_q":0.0,"maximum_passing_q":1.0,"passing_count":21},{"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"per_capita","floor":0.95,"metric":"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control","passing_q":[0.0,0.05,0.1,0.15,0.2,0.25,0.3,0.35,0.4,0.45,0.5,0.55,0.6,0.65,0.7,0.75,0.8,0.85,0.9,0.95,1.0],"minimum_passing_q":0.0,"maximum_passing_q":1.0,"passing_count":21},{"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"per_capita","floor":0.95,"metric":"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1","passing_q":[],"minimum_passing_q":null,"maximum_passing_q":null,"passing_count":0},{"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"per_capita","floor":0.975,"metric":"cumulative_retention_vs_control","passing_q":[0.0,0.05,0.1,0.15,0.2,0.25,0.3,0.35,0.4,0.45,0.5,0.55,0.6,0.65,0.7,0.75,0.8,0.85,0.9,0.95,1.0],"minimum_passing_q":0.0,"maximum_passing_q":1.0,"passing_count":21},{"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"per_capita","floor":0.975,"metric":"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control","passing_q":[0.0,0.05,0.1,0.15,0.2,0.25,0.3,0.35,0.4,0.45,0.5,0.55,0.6,0.65,0.7,0.75,0.8,0.85,0.9,0.95,1.0],"minimum_passing_q":0.0,"maximum_passing_q":1.0,"passing_count":21},{"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"per_capita","floor":0.975,"metric":"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1","passing_q":[],"minimum_passing_q":null,"maximum_passing_q":null,"passing_count":0},{"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"per_capita","floor":0.99,"metric":"cumulative_retention_vs_control","passing_q":[0.0,0.05,0.1,0.15,0.2,0.25,0.3,0.35,0.4,0.45,0.5,0.55,0.6,0.65,0.7,0.75,0.8,0.85,0.9,0.95,1.0],"minimum_passing_q":0.0,"maximum_passing_q":1.0,"passing_count":21},{"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"per_capita","floor":0.99,"metric":"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control","passing_q":[0.0,0.05,0.1,0.15,0.2,0.25,0.3,0.35,0.4,0.45,0.5,0.55,0.6,0.65,0.7,0.75,0.8,0.85,0.9],"minimum_passing_q":0.0,"maximum_passing_q":0.9,"passing_count":19},{"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"per_capita","floor":0.99,"metric":"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1","passing_q":[],"minimum_passing_q":null,"maximum_passing_q":null,"passing_count":0},{"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"displacement_cohorts","floor":0.9,"metric":"cumulative_retention_vs_control","passing_q":[0.0,0.05,0.1,0.15,0.2,0.25,0.3,0.35,0.4,0.45,0.5,0.55,0.6,0.65,0.7,0.75,0.8,0.85,0.9,0.95,1.0],"minimum_passing_q":0.0,"maximum_passing_q":1.0,"passing_count":21},{"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"displacement_cohorts","floor":0.9,"metric":"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control","passing_q":[0.0,0.05,0.1,0.15,0.2,0.25,0.3,0.35,0.4,0.45,0.5,0.55,0.6,0.65,0.7,0.75,0.8,0.85,0.9,0.95,1.0],"minimum_passing_q":0.0,"maximum_passing_q":1.0,"passing_count":21},{"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"displacement_cohorts","floor":0.9,"metric":"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1","passing_q":[],"minimum_passing_q":null,"maximum_passing_q":null,"passing_count":0},{"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"displacement_cohorts","floor":0.95,"metric":"cumulative_retention_vs_control","passing_q":[0.0,0.05,0.1,0.15,0.2,0.25,0.3,0.35,0.4,0.45,0.5,0.55,0.6,0.65,0.7,0.75,0.8,0.85,0.9,0.95,1.0],"minimum_passing_q":0.0,"maximum_passing_q":1.0,"passing_count":21},{"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"displacement_cohorts","floor":0.95,"metric":"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control","passing_q":[0.0,0.05,0.1,0.15,0.2,0.25,0.3,0.35,0.4,0.45,0.5,0.55,0.6,0.65,0.7,0.75,0.8,0.85,0.9],"minimum_passing_q":0.0,"maximum_passing_q":0.9,"passing_count":19},{"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"displacement_cohorts","floor":0.95,"metric":"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1","passing_q":[],"minimum_passing_q":null,"maximum_passing_q":null,"passing_count":0},{"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"displacement_cohorts","floor":0.975,"metric":"cumulative_retention_vs_control","passing_q":[0.0,0.05,0.1,0.15,0.2,0.25,0.3,0.35,0.4,0.45,0.5,0.55,0.6],"minimum_passing_q":0.0,"maximum_passing_q":0.6,"passing_count":13},{"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"displacement_cohorts","floor":0.975,"metric":"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control","passing_q":[0.0,0.05,0.1,0.15,0.2,0.25,0.3,0.35,0.4,0.45],"minimum_passing_q":0.0,"maximum_passing_q":0.45,"passing_count":10},{"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"displacement_cohorts","floor":0.975,"metric":"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1","passing_q":[],"minimum_passing_q":null,"maximum_passing_q":null,"passing_count":0},{"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"displacement_cohorts","floor":0.99,"metric":"cumulative_retention_vs_control","passing_q":[0.0,0.05,0.1,0.15,0.2,0.25],"minimum_passing_q":0.0,"maximum_passing_q":0.25,"passing_count":6},{"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"displacement_cohorts","floor":0.99,"metric":"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control","passing_q":[0.0,0.05,0.1],"minimum_passing_q":0.0,"maximum_passing_q":0.1,"passing_count":3},{"tax_timing":"quarter_end","policy":"displacement_cohorts","floor":0.99,"metric":"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1","passing_q":[],"minimum_passing_q":null,"maximum_passing_q":null,"passing_count":0},{"tax_timing":"december","policy":"owners_only","floor":0.9,"metric":"cumulative_retention_vs_control","passing_q":[0.0,0.05,0.1,0.15,0.2,0.25,0.3,0.35,0.4,0.45,0.5,0.55,0.6,0.65,0.7,0.75,0.8,0.85,0.9,0.95,1.0],"minimum_passing_q":0.0,"maximum_passing_q":1.0,"passing_count":21},{"tax_timing":"december","policy":"owners_only","floor":0.9,"metric":"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control","passing_q":[0.0,0.05,0.1,0.15,0.2,0.25,0.3,0.35,0.4,0.45,0.5,0.55,0.6,0.65,0.7,0.75,0.8,0.85,0.9,0.95,1.0],"minimum_passing_q":0.0,"maximum_passing_q":1.0,"passing_count":21},{"tax_timing":"december","policy":"owners_only","floor":0.9,"metric":"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1","passing_q":[],"minimum_passing_q":null,"maximum_passing_q":null,"passing_count":0},{"tax_timing":"december","policy":"owners_only","floor":0.95,"metric":"cumulative_retention_vs_control","passing_q":[0.0,0.05,0.1,0.15,0.2,0.25,0.3,0.35,0.4,0.45,0.5,0.55,0.6,0.65,0.7,0.75,0.8,0.85,0.9,0.95,1.0],"minimum_passing_q":0.0,"maximum_passing_q":1.0,"passing_count":21},{"tax_timing":"december","policy":"owners_only","floor":0.95,"metric":"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control","passing_q":[0.0,0.05,0.1,0.15,0.2,0.25,0.3,0.35,0.4,0.45,0.5,0.55,0.6,0.65,0.7,0.75,0.8,0.85,0.9,0.95,1.0],"minimum_passing_q":0.0,"maximum_passing_q":1.0,"passing_count":21},{"tax_timing":"december","policy":"owners_only","floor":0.95,"metric":"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1","passing_q":[],"minimum_passing_q":null,"maximum_passing_q":null,"passing_count":0},{"tax_timing":"december","policy":"owners_only","floor":0.975,"metric":"cumulative_retention_vs_control","passing_q":[0.0,0.05,0.1,0.15,0.2,0.25,0.3,0.35,0.4,0.45,0.5,0.55,0.6,0.65,0.7,0.75,0.8,0.85,0.9,0.95,1.0],"minimum_passing_q":0.0,"maximum_passing_q":1.0,"passing_count":21},{"tax_timing":"december","policy":"owners_only","floor":0.975,"metric":"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control","passing_q":[0.0,0.05,0.1,0.15,0.2,0.25,0.3,0.35,0.4,0.45,0.5,0.55,0.6,0.65,0.7,0.75,0.8,0.85,0.9,0.95,1.0],"minimum_passing_q":0.0,"maximum_passing_q":1.0,"passing_count":21},{"tax_timing":"december","policy":"owners_only","floor":0.975,"metric":"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1","passing_q":[],"minimum_passing_q":null,"maximum_passing_q":null,"passing_count":0},{"tax_timing":"december","policy":"owners_only","floor":0.99,"metric":"cumulative_retention_vs_control","passing_q":[0.0,0.05,0.1,0.15,0.2,0.25,0.3,0.35,0.4,0.45,0.5,0.55,0.6,0.65,0.7,0.75,0.8,0.85,0.9,0.95,1.0],"minimum_passing_q":0.0,"maximum_passing_q":1.0,"passing_count":21},{"tax_timing":"december","policy":"owners_only","floor":0.99,"metric":"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control","passing_q":[0.0,0.05,0.1,0.15,0.2,0.25,0.3,0.35,0.4,0.45,0.5,0.55,0.6,0.65,0.7,0.75,0.8,0.85,0.9,0.95,1.0],"minimum_passing_q":0.0,"maximum_passing_q":1.0,"passing_count":21},{"tax_timing":"december","policy":"owners_only","floor":0.99,"metric":"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1","passing_q":[],"minimum_passing_q":null,"maximum_passing_q":null,"passing_count":0},{"tax_timing":"december","policy":"per_capita","floor":0.9,"metric":"cumulative_retention_vs_control","passing_q":[0.0,0.05,0.1,0.15,0.2,0.25,0.3,0.35,0.4,0.45,0.5,0.55,0.6,0.65,0.7,0.75,0.8,0.85,0.9,0.95,1.0],"minimum_passing_q":0.0,"maximum_passing_q":1.0,"passing_count":21},{"tax_timing":"december","policy":"per_capita","floor":0.9,"metric":"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control","passing_q":[0.0,0.05,0.1,0.15,0.2,0.25,0.3,0.35,0.4,0.45,0.5,0.55,0.6,0.65,0.7,0.75,0.8,0.85,0.9,0.95,1.0],"minimum_passing_q":0.0,"maximum_passing_q":1.0,"passing_count":21},{"tax_timing":"december","policy":"per_capita","floor":0.9,"metric":"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1","passing_q":[],"minimum_passing_q":null,"maximum_passing_q":null,"passing_count":0},{"tax_timing":"december","policy":"per_capita","floor":0.95,"metric":"cumulative_retention_vs_control","passing_q":[0.0,0.05,0.1,0.15,0.2,0.25,0.3,0.35,0.4,0.45,0.5,0.55,0.6,0.65,0.7,0.75,0.8,0.85,0.9,0.95,1.0],"minimum_passing_q":0.0,"maximum_passing_q":1.0,"passing_count":21},{"tax_timing":"december","policy":"per_capita","floor":0.95,"metric":"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control","passing_q":[0.0,0.05,0.1,0.15,0.2,0.25,0.3,0.35,0.4,0.45,0.5,0.55,0.6,0.65,0.7,0.75,0.8],"minimum_passing_q":0.0,"maximum_passing_q":0.8,"passing_count":17},{"tax_timing":"december","policy":"per_capita","floor":0.95,"metric":"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1","passing_q":[],"minimum_passing_q":null,"maximum_passing_q":null,"passing_count":0},{"tax_timing":"december","policy":"per_capita","floor":0.975,"metric":"cumulative_retention_vs_control","passing_q":[0.0,0.05,0.1,0.15,0.2,0.25,0.3,0.35,0.4,0.45,0.5,0.55],"minimum_passing_q":0.0,"maximum_passing_q":0.55,"passing_count":12},{"tax_timing":"december","policy":"per_capita","floor":0.975,"metric":"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control","passing_q":[0.0,0.05,0.1,0.15,0.2,0.25,0.3,0.35,0.4],"minimum_passing_q":0.0,"maximum_passing_q":0.4,"passing_count":9},{"tax_timing":"december","policy":"per_capita","floor":0.975,"metric":"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1","passing_q":[],"minimum_passing_q":null,"maximum_passing_q":null,"passing_count":0},{"tax_timing":"december","policy":"per_capita","floor":0.99,"metric":"cumulative_retention_vs_control","passing_q":[0.0,0.05,0.1,0.15,0.2],"minimum_passing_q":0.0,"maximum_passing_q":0.2,"passing_count":5},{"tax_timing":"december","policy":"per_capita","floor":0.99,"metric":"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control","passing_q":[0.0,0.05,0.1,0.15],"minimum_passing_q":0.0,"maximum_passing_q":0.15,"passing_count":4},{"tax_timing":"december","policy":"per_capita","floor":0.99,"metric":"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1","passing_q":[],"minimum_passing_q":null,"maximum_passing_q":null,"passing_count":0},{"tax_timing":"december","policy":"displacement_cohorts","floor":0.9,"metric":"cumulative_retention_vs_control","passing_q":[],"minimum_passing_q":null,"maximum_passing_q":null,"passing_count":0},{"tax_timing":"december","policy":"displacement_cohorts","floor":0.9,"metric":"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control","passing_q":[],"minimum_passing_q":null,"maximum_passing_q":null,"passing_count":0},{"tax_timing":"december","policy":"displacement_cohorts","floor":0.9,"metric":"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1","passing_q":[],"minimum_passing_q":null,"maximum_passing_q":null,"passing_count":0},{"tax_timing":"december","policy":"displacement_cohorts","floor":0.95,"metric":"cumulative_retention_vs_control","passing_q":[],"minimum_passing_q":null,"maximum_passing_q":null,"passing_count":0},{"tax_timing":"december","policy":"displacement_cohorts","floor":0.95,"metric":"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control","passing_q":[],"minimum_passing_q":null,"maximum_passing_q":null,"passing_count":0},{"tax_timing":"december","policy":"displacement_cohorts","floor":0.95,"metric":"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1","passing_q":[],"minimum_passing_q":null,"maximum_passing_q":null,"passing_count":0},{"tax_timing":"december","policy":"displacement_cohorts","floor":0.975,"metric":"cumulative_retention_vs_control","passing_q":[],"minimum_passing_q":null,"maximum_passing_q":null,"passing_count":0},{"tax_timing":"december","policy":"displacement_cohorts","floor":0.975,"metric":"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control","passing_q":[],"minimum_passing_q":null,"maximum_passing_q":null,"passing_count":0},{"tax_timing":"december","policy":"displacement_cohorts","floor":0.975,"metric":"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1","passing_q":[],"minimum_passing_q":null,"maximum_passing_q":null,"passing_count":0},{"tax_timing":"december","policy":"displacement_cohorts","floor":0.99,"metric":"cumulative_retention_vs_control","passing_q":[],"minimum_passing_q":null,"maximum_passing_q":null,"passing_count":0},{"tax_timing":"december","policy":"displacement_cohorts","floor":0.99,"metric":"minimum_annual_retention_vs_control","passing_q":[],"minimum_passing_q":null,"maximum_passing_q":null,"passing_count":0},{"tax_timing":"december","policy":"displacement_cohorts","floor":0.99,"metric":"minimum_annual_vs_control_year1","passing_q":[],"minimum_passing_q":null,"maximum_passing_q":null,"passing_count":0}],"source_sha256":{"annual_monthly_bridge_v106.py":"594dc3457992610fb851dbeb32798fca3ec1fe6da9f07c7c9795da4dd9a76849","capital_feedback_v74.py":"9b08922ac50e6d870ea62812450b76d502dd46cc46762070e54f8aa4e3bf0c45","corporate_credit_ledger_v98.py":"ed39de1b092e597fb111d322b443866e1b342adcf38dd9005756340b241aaf5f","corporate_workout_ledger_v100.py":"740a662f1259cac4995a34473f0dbb420e37c5a6f3ab3eec94c79f4a40e435e8","corporate_workout_model_v100.py":"aa4eda0aa2eb512458ef4d66c7f10e0e8701608f717b6e506e743eb92de9add0","coupled_thesis_v71.py":"09fdb791524844072137e34b4e82a2978ec127d75ab1c15711ef50d1a2664c25","credit_ledger_v77.py":"5a2a3f5526deced577c42985e3e90eaed06c2fc5bf1f9e11ec4707d8ff5f38a8","financed_fiscal_buffer_v108.py":"295a8f891717ef69aa4f6bf3afc7de644aa5b8dd610006f744536efd94920d90","household_distribution_v72.py":"697348d042f608d7ff90cc901870cc40bd78ce96b9e75cd243506240ea2523b8","household_tax_incidence_v109.py":"38c23fc0442c684ce1be78a6d1c9f98ba316906a6d584c7320854ed45fc15e11","household_tax_response_v110.py":"f065ae73522637e2e465172f440e1aed19811910361fa36669b1cdae71c2de30","housing_stress_v75.py":"8b6194f5ced86fb52155ab53349adb9f8930749fcac0647f0dc622a705ecc413","monthly_fiscal_bridge_v107.py":"cf78a613db2fb0519e2dd00408dae8b2e1d441b3e7a4bb2141641e013f7d631f","monthly_transfer_v105.py":"0a31d6d63d63694bca9d428d187cef1516a9ad3eec79d4ed77160cdaf60b57c4","purchasing_power_frontier_v113.py":"8c770f9d115765577723c51a5c868507d67ae96b37d708e107693f740ca06737","saving_asset_sensitivity_v73.py":"153c79caa37286fdaa64488abdebe977348a014d12fc4f07cfdadb0759089a37"}}